---
title: "A successful poem says what a poet wants to say, and more, with parti… — Randall Jarrell Quote #42 | QuotesBy.net"
description: "A successful poem says what a poet wants to say, and more, with particular finality. The remarks he makes about his poems are incidental when the poe… — a quote by Randall Jarrell."
image: "https://quotesby.net/wp-content/themes/quotesby-editorial/assets/og-default.png"
---

> # A successful poem says what a poet wants to say, and more, with particular finality. The remarks he makes about his poems are incidental when the poem is good, or embarrassing or absurd when it is bad - and he is not permitted to say how the good poem is good, and may never know how the bad poem is bad. It is better to write about other people's poetry.

[Randall Jarrell](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell)\#42

[Poetry](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/poetry/)[Writing](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/writing/)[Criticism](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/criticism/)[Work](https://quotesby.net/topics/work/)

[WhatsApp (opens in a new tab)](https://wa.me/?text=%E2%80%9CA%20successful%20poem%20says%20what%20a%20poet%20wants%20to%20say%2C%20and%20more%2C%20with%20particular%20finality.%20The%20remarks%20he%20makes%20about%20his%20poems%20are%20incidental%20when%20the%20poem%20is%20good%2C%20or%20embarrassing%20or%20absurd%20when%20it%20is%20bad%20-%20and%20he%20is%20not%20permitted%20to%20say%20how%20the%20good%20poem%20is%20good%2C%20and%20may%20never%20know%20how%20the%20bad%20poem%20is%20bad.%20It%20is%20better%20to%20write%20about%20other%20people%27s%20poetry.%E2%80%9D%20%E2%80%94%20Randall%20Jarrell%20https%3A%2F%2Fquotesby.net%2FRandall-Jarrell%2F42%2F)[X (opens in a new tab)](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=%E2%80%9CA%20successful%20poem%20says%20what%20a%20poet%20wants%20to%20say%2C%20and%20more%2C%20with%20particular%20finality.%20The%20remarks%20he%20makes%20about%20his%20poems%20are%20incidental%20when%20the%20poem%20is%20good%2C%20or%20embarrassing%20or%20absurd%20when%20it%20is%20bad%20-%20and%20he%20is%20not%20permitted%20to%20say%20how%20the%20good%20poem%20is%20good%2C%20and%20may%20never%20know%20how%20the%20bad%20poem%20is%20bad.%20It%20is%20better%20to%20write%20about%20other%20people%27s%20poetry.%E2%80%9D%20%E2%80%94%20Randall%20Jarrell&url=https%3A%2F%2Fquotesby.net%2FRandall-Jarrell%2F42%2F)[Facebook (opens in a new tab)](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fquotesby.net%2FRandall-Jarrell%2F42%2F)

## About this quote

What does it mean?A good poem speaks on its own; the poet's explanation is incidental or embarrassing.In plain termsGood poems explain themselves; poet explanations often fail.What can you take from it?Let the work speak for itself.

### Where it applies

- criticism
- writing advice
- evaluation

### Putting it to work

- review the work
- avoid over-explaining
- judge the text

### Questions to consider

- Can art explain itself?
- Do comments help?

### Another view

Poets sometimes offer helpful context.

## More from Randall Jarrell

1. > It is better to have the child in the chimney corner moved by what happens in the poem, in spite of his ignorance of its real meaning, than to have the poem a …

[Permalink to quote \#41](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/41/ "Permalink to quote 41")
2. > Most of us know, now, that Rousseau was wrong: that man, when you knock his chains off, sets up the death camps. Soon we shall know everything the eighteenth c…

[Permalink to quote \#43](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/43/ "Permalink to quote 43")
3. > One is forced to remember how far from 'self-expression' great poems are - what a strange compromise between the demands of the self, the world, and Poetry the…

[Permalink to quote \#40](https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/40/ "Permalink to quote 40")

## Related quotes

1. > I regard criticism as an art, and if in this country and in this age it is practiced with honesty, it is no more remunerative than the work of an avant-garde f…

[Pauline Kael](https://quotesby.net/Pauline-Kael)[Pauline Kael quote \#1](https://quotesby.net/Pauline-Kael/1/ "Permalink to quote 1")
2. > I don't know of any thing in my book to be criticised on by honourable men. Is it on my spelling? - that's not my trade. Is it on my grammar ? - I hadn't time …

[Davy Crockett](https://quotesby.net/Davy-Crockett)[Davy Crockett quote \#18](https://quotesby.net/Davy-Crockett/18/ "Permalink to quote 18")
3. > Of all fatiguing, futile, empty trades, the worst, I suppose, is writing about writing.

[Hilaire Belloc](https://quotesby.net/Hilaire-Belloc)[Hilaire Belloc quote \#46](https://quotesby.net/Hilaire-Belloc/46/ "Permalink to quote 46")

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "Quotation",
    "text": "A successful poem says what a poet wants to say, and more, with particular finality. The remarks he makes about his poems are incidental when the poem is good, or embarrassing or absurd when it is bad - and he is not permitted to say how the good poem is good, and may never know how the bad poem is bad. It is better to write about other people's poetry.",
    "url": "https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/42/",
    "spokenByCharacter": {
        "@type": "Person",
        "name": "Randall Jarrell"
    }
}
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
    "itemListElement": [
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 1,
            "name": "Home",
            "item": "https://quotesby.net/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 2,
            "name": "Authors",
            "item": "https://quotesby.net/authors/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 3,
            "name": "Randall Jarrell",
            "item": "https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 4,
            "name": "Quote #42",
            "item": "https://quotesby.net/Randall-Jarrell/42/"
        }
    ]
}
```
