---
title: "Who Said ‘The Best Time to Plant a Tree Was 20 Years Ago’? – QuotesBy.net"
description: "Who said the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago? Not Confucius. The trail starts in a 1967 Cleveland newspaper, and the Chinese label came later."
image: "https://quotesby.net/wp-content/themes/quotesby-editorial/assets/og-default.png"
---

# Who Said ‘The Best Time to Plant a Tree Was 20 Years Ago’?

Nobody knows who said it first, and the evidence that it is a Chinese proverb is thin. The earliest printing that researchers have found is from a Cleveland newspaper in March 1967, and that version said the best time to plant a tree was *30* years ago, not 20. The “Chinese proverb” label does not show up in print until 1985.

Below you will find the dated trail of printings, why the number keeps changing, what the honest attribution looks like on a card, a slide or a book page, and a few genuinely sourced lines you can use if you need a name attached.

## The short answer you can repeat with confidence

The saying runs, in its most common modern form: “The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best time is now.” It is usually tagged as a Chinese proverb, sometimes as Confucius, occasionally as an African proverb.

The research site Quote Investigator traced the line through digitised newspapers and published its findings in [a December 2021 entry on the plant-a-tree saying](https://quoteinvestigator.com/2021/12/29/plant-tree/). The conclusion is blunt: the creator is unknown, the saying was circulating by 1967, and he found no substantive evidence that it comes from China.

So the most accurate credit is simply **“Anonymous”** or **“modern proverb”**. If you want to be precise, “earliest known printing 1967” is defensible. “Ancient Chinese proverb” is not.

## Every dated printing, in order

The table below follows the Quote Investigator trail. The “years” column is the detail to watch, because it shows the wording was still loose for decades.

| Year | Where it appeared | Years named | Credited to |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1967 | The Plain Dealer, Cleveland | 30 | “Someone remarked”; a city councilman declined credit |
| 1968 | The North Bay Nugget, Ontario | 80 | No one |
| 1969 | Ottawa Journal, reporting Jean Chretien | 30 | Chretien as speaker, not author |
| 1969 | Congressional Record | 30 | Rep. Benjamin Blackburn as speaker |
| 1975 | Rapid City Journal | “yesterday” | No one |
| 1985 | Lincoln Journal, Nebraska | 20 | “Chinese proverb” |
| 2002 | The Daily Spectrum, Utah | 10 | Confucius, via a reader’s email |

Two things stand out. First, the 20-year version and the Chinese label arrive together, in the same 1985 article, nearly two decades after the saying was already in American and Canadian print. Second, the Confucius credit appears even later and comes from a reader, not from any text.

## Why the number drifts from 30 to 20 to 10

Proverbs that live mostly in speech change shape every time someone repeats them. The number in this one is not load-bearing: the joke works the same whether the tree should have gone in a decade or a lifetime ago. Speakers round it to whatever feels right for their audience.

Twenty probably won because it is long enough to sting and short enough to feel personal. Thirty years ago, many listeners were not yet adults. Twenty years ago, most were, which turns the line from a remark about trees into a remark about you.

Quote Investigator also found earlier, looser relatives: nineteenth-century newspaper advice about when to plant and transplant, and a 1959 health column that used the same “best time was years ago” shape about starting good habits at fifteen. Those are ancestors of the idea, not early printings of the proverb.

## Is it a Chinese proverb at all?

Here is the fair position: no one has produced a Chinese source text, and the Chinese attribution appears late. That does not prove a Chinese speaker never said something similar. It means that, as of the best published research, the label is unsupported.

The pattern is familiar. Western speakers often add “as the Chinese say” to give a homely line extra weight. We looked at the same habit in [our piece on the Confucius and Laozi misquote problem](https://quotesby.net/what-ancient-chinese-philosophy-actually-says-confucius-laozi-and-the-misquote-problem/), where well-known “ancient” sayings turn out to be twentieth-century English.

Chinese does have a well-known tree saying of its own: 十年树木，百年树人, roughly “ten years to grow trees, a hundred years to raise people”. It is listed with a published source on [Wikiquote’s page of Chinese proverbs](https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Chinese_proverbs). Its point is the long labour of education, not regret about lost time, so it cannot serve as a source for the “20 years ago” line.

## Quick check: can you put a name on it?

- **“Chinese proverb”**: not supported by any known source. Avoid.
- **“Confucius”**: no basis. Earliest Confucius credit found is a 2002 reader email. Avoid.
- **“African proverb”**: no published evidence either. Avoid.
- **“Anonymous” or “Proverb”**: accurate. Use this.
- **“Anonymous, in print by 1967”**: accurate and more interesting. Use this in anything with footnotes.

## How to use the line without spreading a myth

Most people want this quote for a speech, a retirement card, a fundraising appeal for a tree-planting day, or a slide about starting late. All of those work perfectly well with an honest credit. Three ways to do it:

1. **On a slide or social post:** write the quote and put “Anonymous” underneath. Nobody will notice the absence of China. Fact-checkers will notice its presence.
2. **In a speech:** “There’s an old saying, often called a Chinese proverb though no one has ever found it in Chinese, that the best time to plant a tree was twenty years ago.” The aside earns a small laugh and makes you look careful.
3. **In print with citations:** credit it as a proverb and cite Quote Investigator’s 2021 entry, which gives the 1967 Plain Dealer printing.

If the point of your talk is starting something late, such as a language, an instrument or a degree, the proverb pairs well with practical reassurance. [This honest answer on whether it is too late to learn something new](https://lifelearningjourney.com/is-it-too-late-to-learn/) covers the evidence on adult learning and what actually changes with age.

And if you are literally planting trees, the proverb’s logic is sound: trees take years to give shade. Budget for them alongside the rest of the garden, because [planting and landscaping costs](https://1hsc.com/landscaping-cost-budget-planning-for-front-and-back-yards/) add up faster than most people expect.

## Sourced lines about planting for the future

If your setting really does need a named author, swap in a documented line rather than inventing a credit. [Our guide to proverbs and anonymous wisdom](https://quotesby.net/proverbs-and-anonymous-wisdom-when-no-one-owns-the-quote/) explains why an anonymous saying is not a weaker quote, just an honest one. For named lines on waiting and long effort, browse [quotations about patience](https://quotesby.net/topics/patience/), and check each one’s source before you print it.

The decision rule is simple. If you cannot name a book, speech, letter or interview, credit the line as a proverb.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Who actually said “the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago”?

No individual author is known. The earliest printing found so far is a March 1967 column in The Plain Dealer in Cleveland, where it appeared as something “someone remarked”, with 30 years rather than 20. The 20-year wording appears in a Nebraska newspaper in 1985. Credit it as a proverb or as anonymous.

### Is it a Chinese proverb?

There is no known Chinese source for it. The label first appears in English print in 1985, long after the saying was already circulating in the United States and Canada. A genuine Chinese saying pairs ten years with growing trees, but it is about raising people over a century, not about planting late.

### Did Confucius say it?

No. Nothing like it appears in the Analects, and the earliest Confucius credit that researchers found came from a reader’s email quoted in a Utah newspaper in 2002. Linking the line to Confucius is one of many cases of a modern saying being given an ancient name to make it sound wiser.

### Is it “20 years ago” or “30 years ago”?

Both are in circulation, along with 10, 80 and “yesterday”. Thirty is the oldest printed number. Twenty is the most common today. Since the saying has no fixed original, either is acceptable, but if you quote the 1967 printing specifically, use thirty.

### Related Articles

[Be Curious, Not Judgmental: Not Whitman, Here's the Story](https://quotesby.net/be-curious-not-judgmental-not-whitman/)

Be curious, not judgmental is not Walt Whitman. Te…

[Quotes Misattributed to Einstein, and Where They Came From](https://quotesby.net/quotes-misattributed-to-einstein/)

Quotes misattributed to Einstein, traced: the insa…

[Gratitude Quotes: Who Really Said the Famous Ones?](https://quotesby.net/gratitude-quotes-who-really-said-them/)

Gratitude quotes, who really said them: six famous…

[Burke Never Said 'All That Is Necessary for Evil to Triumph'](https://quotesby.net/triumph-of-evil-quote-not-burke/)

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil: Bur…

[The Difference Between a Misattributed Quote and the Real Thing](https://quotesby.net/the-difference-between-a-misattributed-quote-and-the-real-thing/)

The internet has made it extraordinarily easy to s…

[Nelson Mandela Quotes: Documented Sources and the Most Famous Misattribution](https://quotesby.net/nelson-mandela-quotes-documented-sources-and-the-most-famous-misattribution/)

Nelson Mandela's words carry the weight of lived e…

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BlogPosting",
    "headline": "Who Said ‘The Best Time to Plant a Tree Was 20 Years Ago’?",
    "description": "Who said the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago? Not Confucius. The trail starts in a 1967 Cleveland newspaper, and the Chinese label came later.",
    "url": "https://quotesby.net/best-time-to-plant-a-tree-quote-origin/",
    "datePublished": "",
    "dateModified": "",
    "author": {
        "@type": "Organization",
        "name": "quotesby.com"
    },
    "publisher": {
        "@type": "Organization",
        "name": "quotesby.com",
        "url": "https://quotesby.net"
    },
    "mainEntityOfPage": {
        "@type": "WebPage",
        "@id": "https://quotesby.net/best-time-to-plant-a-tree-quote-origin/"
    }
}
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
    "itemListElement": [
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 1,
            "name": "Home",
            "item": "https://quotesby.net/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 2,
            "name": "Misattributions",
            "item": "https://quotesby.net/category/misattributions/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 3,
            "name": "Who Said &#8216;The Best Time to Plant a Tree Was 20 Years Ago&#8217;?"
        }
    ]
}
```
