The folksong collectors Bartok (Hungary) and Plicka (Czechoslovakia) notated the perceived interval deviations with a plus or minus sign (+,-). Older folksong collectors had notated all the intervals in the system of semitones, not observing the finer modifications of intervals. This first gained currency from the phongraph and tape recordings of folk music from various lands....From folksong I learned to perceive melodic intervals a little smaller or greater than those of the semitone-system....In my youth it often happened that the folk singers, who during the intermissions of dance festivals sang songs of 'their kind,' deviating from the semitone system, demanded that the first violinist of the Wisowitzer Kapelle play 'their' melody just as they sang it. Once a tempermental singer threatened to strike the double-bass player with a beer mug if he didn't 'play along' with the song, exactly as he sang it.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Early folk song collectors used simple semitone notation, but later collectors noted finer pitch variations, showing the need for more precise musical description.
- In plain terms
- Music notation evolved to capture subtle pitch differences missed by earlier systems.
- What can you take from it?
- Use detailed notation to preserve authentic musical nuances.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How does notation affect cultural transmission?
- When is simplicity preferable to precision?
Another view
Over‑precision can complicate transmission for non‑specialists.
Related quotes
Gershwin's melodic gift was phenomenal. His songs contain the essence of New York in the 1920s and have deservedly become classics of their kind, part of the 2…
George GershwinGeorge Gershwin quote #16 Same thing happened in the Punk Movement in the late 70's. It's like, major labels were signing punk bands right after the band's first gig, y'know, a punk ban…
Kurt Donald CobainKurt Donald Cobain quote #1 On jazz: 'Jazz is known all over the world as an American musical art form and that's it. No America, no jazz. I've seen people try to connect it to other coun…
Art BlakeyArt Blakey quote #1