Skip to content
quotesby

Once the masterpiece has emerged, the lesser works surrounding it fall into place; and it then gives the impression of having been led up to and foreseeable, though actually it is inconceivable - or, rather, it can only be conceived of once it is there for us to see it. It is not a scene that has come alive, but a latent potentiality that has materialized. Suppose that one of the world's masterpieces were to disappear, leaving no trace behind it, not even a reproduction; even the completest knowledge of its maker's other works would not enable the next generation to visualize it. All the rest of Leonardo's oeuvre would not enable us to visualize the Mona Lisa; all Rembrandt's, the Three Crosses or The Prodigal Son; all Vermeer's, The Love Letter; all Titian's, the Venice Pieta; all medieval sculpture, the Chartres Kings or the Naumburg Uta. What would another picture by the Master of Villeneuve look like? How could even the most careful study of The Embarkation for Cythera, or indeed that of all Watteau's other works conjure up L'Enseigne de Gersaint, had it disappeared?

Andre Malraux#18

ArtCreationUniqueness

About this quote

What does it mean?
Masterpieces are unique and unpredictable; they cannot be fully deduced from an artist's other work.
In plain terms
Great works surprise us and can't be predicted from past art.
What can you take from it?
Value masterpieces as singular events that resist replication.

Where it applies

  • art criticism
  • education
  • collection

Putting it to work

  • study outliers
  • avoid reductionism

Questions to consider

  • Why do masterpieces surprise us?
  • Can you predict genius?

Another view

Artists often develop styles that make their masterpieces foreseeable over time.

More from Andre Malraux

  1. If modern painters feel qualms about applying the term 'masterpiece' to describe a work of capital importance, this is because it has come to convey a notion o…

    Permalink to quote #17
  2. Athirst for personal salvation, the West forgets that many religions had but a vague notion of the life beyond the grave; true, all great religions stake a cla…

    Permalink to quote #19
  3. The present age delights in unearthing a great man's secrets; for one thing because we like to temper our admiration and also perhaps we have a vague hope of f…

    Permalink to quote #16

Related quotes

  1. A film is just like a muffin. You make it. You put it on the table. One person might say, 'Oh, I don't like it'. One might say it's the best muffin ever made. …

    Denzel WashingtonDenzel Washington quote #1
  2. I seek a form that my style cannot discover, a bud of thought that wants to be a rose.

    Ruben DarioRuben Dario quote #1
  3. I believe that any 'awareness' of life is 'spiritual' since awareness can only be a quality of the spirit not of the material world or of matter and machines. …

    Chick CoreaChick Corea quote #1