Skip to content
quotesby

Each form of the sacrosanct was regarded by members of the culture which gave rise to it as a revelation of the Truth; at Byzantium it was not a mere hypothesis that was sponsored by the majesty of the Byzantine style. To us, however, these forms make their appeal as forms alone - in other words, as they would be were they the work of a contemporary (and, since this actually is unthinkable, they affect us in a puzzling manner); or else as so many grandiose vestiges of a faith that has died out. We look at them from outside; they are still emotive, but they are no longer true. Thus we deprive them of what was their most vital element; for a religious civilization that regarded what it revered as a mere hypothesis is inconceivable.

Andre Malraux#22

ArtHistoryContextFaithPerspective

About this quote

What does it mean?
Ancient religious art loses meaning when viewed outside its original belief system.
In plain terms
Religious art stops being true when we stop believing in it.
What can you take from it?
Context gives art its power.

Where it applies

  • museum visits
  • art study
  • religious history

Putting it to work

  • learn original context
  • respect beliefs

Questions to consider

  • Does context matter?
  • Can art live without faith?

Another view

Art can still move people without religious belief.

More from Andre Malraux

  1. An individualism which has got beyond the stage of hedonism tends to yield to the lure of the grandiose. It was not man, the individual, nor even the Supreme B…

    Permalink to quote #21
  2. The great Christian art did not die because all possible forms had been used up; it died because faith was being transformed into piety. Now, the same conquest…

    Permalink to quote #23
  3. Surely that little pseudo-gothic church on Broadway, hidden amongst the skyscrapers, is symbolic of the age! On the whole face of the globe the civilization th…

    Permalink to quote #20

Related quotes

  1. Great artists are products of their own time: they do not spring forth fully equipped from the head of Jove, but are formed by the circumstances acting upon th…

    Germaine GreerGermaine Greer quote #15
  2. Providence conceals itself in the details of human affairs, but becomes unveiled in the generalities of history.

    Alphonse de LamartineAlphonse de Lamartine quote #15
  3. The great Christian art did not die because all possible forms had been used up; it died because faith was being transformed into piety. Now, the same conquest…

    Andre MalrauxAndre Malraux quote #23