Skip to content
quotesby

The United States has managed to go to war for two centuries without the president authorizing and monitoring the torture of prisoners. The Bush administration's legalization of torture and withdrawal from Geneva is unique in American history. Yes, wars will lead to individuals committing war crimes in the heat of battle. Yes, it carries a horrifying logic. But an advance, pre-meditated decision by the president to engage in war crimes is new and unprecedented. Bush really is uniquely awful as a president in this respect: an indefensible war criminal, who has permanently stained the country he represents and betrayed the soldiers who expect decency and lawfulness in their commander-in-chief.

Andrew Sullivan#20

TortureHistoryPresidencyWar crimes

About this quote

What does it mean?
The Bush administration's pre-meditated torture decision was unprecedented in US history.
In plain terms
Bush uniquely authorized torture before the fact, unlike past presidents.
What can you take from it?
Pre-planned torture is a unique breach of US norms.

Where it applies

  • historical comparison
  • policy critique
  • legal review

Putting it to work

  • compare presidential actions
  • evaluate war crimes

Questions to consider

  • What makes this unique?
  • How should war crimes be judged?

Another view

Some argue wartime necessities justify exceptions.

More from Andrew Sullivan

  1. When you fuse Christianity with power, it isn't long before Christians start imposing the cross on others rather than taking it up for themselves.

    Permalink to quote #19
  2. When Bush says that Abu Ghraib was the work of a few, he forgot to mention that he was one of them.

    Permalink to quote #21
  3. That's what torture does: it creates a miasma of unknowing, about as dangerous a situation in wartime as one can imagine. This hideous fate was made possible b…

    Permalink to quote #18

Related quotes

  1. You will have very large quantities of clothes to disinfect, ten or twenty times as much as the 'Textiles Collection,' which is only being carried out in order…

    Odilo GlobocnikOdilo Globocnik quote #2
  2. I assumed that some of the gold bars I received were melted gold teeth.

    Oswald PohlOswald Pohl quote #2
  3. ...Block 10 was made up of mostly married women between the ages of 20 and 40, preferably those who had not borne children. There was a constant fear in Block …

    Carl ClaubergCarl Clauberg quote #3