Skip to content
quotesby

Torture was necessary to maintain slavery. It was integral to slavery. You cannot have slavery without some torture or the threat of torture; and you cannot have torture without slavery. You cannot imprison a free man for ever unless you have broken him; and you can only forcibly break a man's soul by torturing it out of him. Slavery dehumanizes; torture dehumanizes in exactly the same way. The torture of human beings who have no freedom and no recourse to the courts is slavery.

Andrew Sullivan#4

TortureHistoryJusticeEthicsHuman rightsDehumanizationSlavery

About this quote

What does it mean?
The speaker links torture and slavery as mutually dehumanizing systems where one necessitates the other to maintain control.
In plain terms
Torture and slavery destroy human dignity together; you cannot have one without the other.
What can you take from it?
Systematic abuse and captivity are inherently linked and dehumanizing.

Where it applies

  • human rights law
  • historical analysis
  • justice reform

Putting it to work

  • advocating bans
  • researching historical abuses
  • supporting survivors

Questions to consider

  • How does physical coercion affect the soul?
  • Can any system of control be truly humane?

Another view

Equating all forms of control risks diluting the specific legal definitions of slavery.

More from Andrew Sullivan

  1. First silence. Then denial. Then support of the insupportable. Then vilification of the dissenters. The pattern is as old as time.

    Permalink to quote #3
  2. In thinking about the costs of this war, and thinking about renewing it, we have to reconsider what it has done to America. It has turned the U.S. military int…

    Permalink to quote #5
  3. Today's age of politicized and intolerant Christianism seems to me to be one of those moments when Christianity has estranged itself most thoroughly from the p…

    Permalink to quote #2

Related quotes

  1. Slaves no doubt, but still men.

    Ambrosius Theodosius MacrobiusAmbrosius Theodosius Macrobius quote #1
  2. The men and women of the North are slaveholders, those of the South slaveowners. The guilt rests on the North equally with the South.

    Susan B. AnthonySusan B. Anthony quote #2
  3. In returning I read a very different book, published by an honest Quaker, on that execrable sum of all villanies, commonly called the Slave-trade.

    John WesleyJohn Wesley quote #8