There remains the ordinary Communist solution. This has taken various forms; the simplest being a voluntary association of individuals based on the principle of common property, and in which every person works for the community according to fixed rules. There are many successful instances of this, on a small scale, in the United States, but we cannot suppose such a solution to be possible for society as a whole. It has only been tried with picked materials, whereas our object is rather to improve the great mass of the population. The Communism of recent European theorists, of whom the best known is Lassalle, presents a somewhat different aspect. It aims at the appropriation of all instruments of production by the State, which is to take charge of the whole national industry and direct it. But the practical difficulty of such a scheme is obviously overwhelming. The objections to a Communistic solution do not apply to Socialism in a more modified shape. Historically speaking, Socialism has already shown itself in England in the extension of State interference. It has produced the Factory Laws, and it is now beginning to advance further and interfere directly in the division of produce between the workmen and their employers
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Communist ideas of voluntary common‑property associations work on a small scale, but scaling them to whole societies is impractical; state‑run production faces overwhelming difficulties.
- In plain terms
- Small communal economies can succeed, but scaling them or state control is impractical.
- What can you take from it?
- Recognize the limits of communal and state‑centralized economic models at large scales.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What conditions enable small communal models to scale?
- How can state involvement be balanced with local autonomy?
Another view
Some large‑scale cooperatives have shown partial success, challenging the blanket claim.
More from Arnold Toynbee
The Comtists are right when they say that men's moral ideas are not fixed. The attitude of public opinion towards slavery was completely changed in twenty or t…
Permalink to quote #9 We must remember that the real problem is not how to produce some improvement in the condition of the working man- for that has to a certain extent been attain…
Permalink to quote #11 We must expect for a long time yet to see capitalists still striving to obtain the highest possible profits. But observe, that the passion for wealth is certai…
Permalink to quote #8
Related quotes
If one rejects laissez faire on account of mans fallibility and moral weakness, one must for the same reason also reject every kind of government action. -- Pl…
Ludwig von MisesLudwig von Mises quote #1 Derangement is the signature expression of the Great Backlash, a style of conservatism that first came snarling onto the national stage in response to the part…
Thomas FrankThomas Frank quote #1 A national debt, if it is not excessive, will be to us a national blessing.
Alexander HamiltonAlexander Hamilton quote #1