According to the world's highest medical authorities, burns extending over 75 per cent of a person's body are regarded as likely to prove fatal. The burns of these two patients were not only extensive but also deep, even involving their muscles in many places. Therefore all the experienced surgeons frowned, shook their heads, and expressed their utter inability to save the lives of these men. One of them said, 'It is only a matter of three or four days.' Another suggested, 'At most three days.' Still a third one said, 'Whether medicine is used or not is immaterial, for in spite of all efforts the patients will die.' Everybody seemed to agree on one conclusion 'death.' In this way the joint consultation was concluded in a very pessimistic and hopeless atmosphere. On the basis of mortality statistics in international medical literature it seemed that these badly burned patients were doomed to die. But the Party organization of the hospital would not agree to such a pessimistic view. The secretary of the general Party branch and the assistant secretary of the medical department branch immediately summoned the doctors treating the patients for a talk, and following that a meeting of all the responsible doctors was convened. The problem was analysed from a class viewpoint, and it was stressed that in capitalist countries it was impossible to obtain the full use of all resources to save the lives of burned workers, but that in our socialist country it was possible to mobilize everything available to save them. For this reason we should not always accept the medical statistics of capitalist countries and allow them to influence us. The Party secretary called the attention of the doctors specially to the following points: First, that they must try to rid themselves of their blind reliance on established bourgeois medical experience, and they must try to think, speak and act in bold new ways. Secondly, they must follow the mass line and depend more upon the power of the people. Finally he said, 'The Party will do everything possible to save these steel workers who have created vast wealth for the nation.'
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Medical experts declared severe burn victims beyond saving based on statistics and experience.
- In plain terms
- Doctors said the patients would die based on past data.
- What can you take from it?
- Statistics can sometimes limit medical hope.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When should we trust data over individual cases?
- How do you face a hopeless diagnosis?
Another view
Medical statistics do not account for individual variability.
More from Ba Jin
Today I read your autobiography in two volumes, Living My Life. These two books full of life, shocked me greatly. Your roaring of forty years like spring thund…
Permalink to quote #14 When they accepted their assignments they were not very confident, especially the assistant head surgeon who simply believed in his own past experience, in the…
Permalink to quote #16 Now my education, life and consciousness are talked about by those who cannot understand what I wrote, what I think, what is my life. They make me up from thei…
Permalink to quote #13
Related quotes
Physicians of the Utmost Fame Were called at once; but when they came they murmured as they took their fees, 'There is no cure for this disease.'
Hilaire BellocHilaire Belloc quote #48 We went through the records and we found over five hundred of his patients who were alive and well five years after their treatment, with no cancer. And Dr. Bu…
Gary NullGary Null quote #1 A physician can sometimes parry the scythe of death, but has no power over the sand in the hourglass.
Hester ThraleHester Thrale quote #2