When a physician sees that his patient's strength is being exhausted so rapidly by the intensity of his agony that he will die of exhaustion before the medical processes inaugurated have a chance to do their curative work, he administers an opiate. But a good physician is always loath to do so, knowing that one of the influences of the opiate is to interfere with and defeat the medical processes themselves. He never does it except as a choice of evils. It is the same with the use of force, whether of the mob or of the State, upon diseased society; and not only those who prescribe its indiscriminate use as a sovereign remedy and a permanent tonic, but all who ever propose it as a cure, and even all who would lightly and unnecessarily resort to it, not as a cure, but as an expedient, are social quacks.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Using force on society is like giving opium to a patient; it offers temporary relief but undermines long-term healing.
- In plain terms
- Force might help short term but hurts society's ability to fix itself.
- What can you take from it?
- Avoid using force as a quick fix for social problems.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can society heal without intervention?
- When is pain necessary for cure?
Another view
Sometimes immediate force is needed to stop greater harm.
More from Benjamin Tucker
The idea that Anarchy can be inaugurated by force is as fallacious as the idea that it can be sustained by force. Force cannot preserve Anarchy; neither can it…
Permalink to quote #36 Passive resistance and boycotting are now prominent features of every great national movement.
Permalink to quote #38 'Passive resistance,' said Ferdinand Lassalle, with an obtuseness thoroughly German, 'is the resistance which does not resist.' Never was there a greater mista…
Permalink to quote #35
Related quotes
In the next ten years we will have to continue to make changes which will make the whole of this country a genuinely classless society.
John MajorJohn Major quote #1 Revolution is a trivial shift in the emphasis of suffering; the capacity for self-indulgence changes hands.
Tom StoppardTom Stoppard quote #1 Mother, mother There's too many of you crying. Brother, brother, brother There's far too many of you dying. You know we've got to find a way To bring some lovi…
Marvin GayeMarvin Gaye quote #1