Skip to content
quotesby

Dickens was a pure modernist - a leader of the steam-whistle party par excellence - and he had no understanding of any power of antiquity except a sort of jackdaw sentiment for cathedral towers. He knew nothing of the nobler power of superstition - was essentially a stage manager, and used everything for effect on the pit. His Christmas meant mistletoe and pudding - neither resurrection from dead, nor rising of new stars, nor teaching of wise men, nor shepherds. His hero is essentially the ironmaster.

Charles Dickens#150

SuperstitionTradition

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author critiques Dickens for lacking depth in tradition and superstition, viewing him as a showman rather than a profound thinker.
In plain terms
Dickens focused on surface effects instead of deep traditions.
What can you take from it?
Great art often requires understanding deeper historical or spiritual powers.

Where it applies

  • analyzing authors
  • discussing literary style

Putting it to work

  • seek depth in art
  • understand context

Questions to consider

  • Does accessibility undermine literary depth?
  • How much should art reflect tradition?

Another view

This critique dismisses the value of accessible storytelling.

More from Charles Dickens

  1. He had a large loving mind and the strongest sympathy with the poorer classes. He felt sure a better feeling, and much greater union of classes, would take pla…

    Permalink to quote #149
  2. The art of Dickens was the most exquisite of arts: it was the art of enjoying everybody. Dickens, being a very human writer, had to be a very human being; he h…

    Permalink to quote #151
  3. A splendid muse of fiction hath Charles Dickens, But now and then just as the interest thickens He stilts his pathos, and the reader sickens.

    Permalink to quote #148

Related quotes

  1. Nothing in all the world is so nonsensical and contradictory, save mortals, that is, who live in the grip of the superstitions of the past.

    Anne RiceAnne Rice quote #12
  2. Because most religions offer no valid mechanism by which their core beliefs can be tested and revised, each new generation of believers is condemned to inherit…

    Sam HarrisSam Harris quote #25
  3. You have no business to be an unbeliever. You ought to stand for all the things these stupid people call superstitions. Come now, don't you think there's a lot…

    Gilbert Keith ChestertonGilbert Keith Chesterton quote #167