Skip to content
quotesby

I could scarcely keep from laughing at this scrupulous manner of waging war. I cited the European example as a much more forceful policy. A monarch is careful not to overlook any advantage for victory. She had some questions about that: 'Tell me,' she said, 'do your princes have no other pretext for war than might makes right?' 'Yes,' I answered, 'the justice of their cause.' 'Why, then,' she continued, 'do they not choose to be reconciled by impartial judges? And if it is determined that both sides are in the right, then why not maintain the status quo? Or why not play a game of gin rummy for the town or province they're arguing over? But no, while they cause the death of four million men who are better than they, they stay in their strategy rooms making light of the way the poor fellows are being massacred. But I'm wrong to criticize the valour of your brave men. It's important to die for one's country when it means being the subject of a king who wears a ruffled collar or a pleated one.'

Cyrano de Bergerac#32

PowerWarCriticismJusticePeacePolitics

About this quote

What does it mean?
The narrator criticizes European warfare as absurd, noting that powerful leaders use force rather than impartial judgment to resolve disputes.
In plain terms
War is criticized because leaders use force instead of fair judges.
What can you take from it?
Use judgment instead of force to resolve disputes.

Where it applies

  • anti-war critique
  • political analysis
  • ethics

Putting it to work

  • question war motives
  • advocate arbitration

Questions to consider

  • Why do nations fight instead of settling differences?
  • Is might truly right?

Another view

The critique assumes leaders always avoid impartial solutions.

More from Cyrano de Bergerac

  1. Even if a king defeats his enemy in battle, that still doesn't settle anything. There are other, less numerous armies of philosophers and scientists, and their…

    Permalink to quote #31
  2. You praise a man for having killed his enemy by means of an advantage; and by praising him for boldness you praise him for a sin against nature, because boldne…

    Permalink to quote #33
  3. People were soon talking only of my bons mots, and they esteemed my wit so highly that the clergy was forced to publish a decree that forbade anyone to believe…

    Permalink to quote #30

Related quotes

  1. What argument have they to persuade the young men to fight except merely in another squalid attempt to defend themselves against a redistribution of the intern…

    Aneurin BevanAneurin Bevan quote #3
  2. Iraq is an unjust war. (spoken on the Diane Rehm Show; stated in articles written for NY Times; printed in USA Today)

    Jimmy CarterJimmy Carter quote #10
  3. This war has been motivated by pride or arrogance, by a desire to control oil wealth, by a desire to implant our programs. (on the Diane Rehm Show.

    Jimmy CarterJimmy Carter quote #11