Skip to content
quotesby

You will say, 'How can chance assemble in one place all the things necessary to produce an oak tree?' My answer is that it would be no miracle if the matter thus arranged had not formed an oak. But it would have been a very great miracle if, once the matter was thus arranged, an oak had not been formed. A few less of some shapes, and it would have been an elm, a poplar, a willow, an elder, heather or moss. A little more of some other shapes and it might have been a sensitive plant, an oyster in its shell, a worm, a fly, a frog, a sparrow, an ape or a man.

Cyrano de Bergerac#43

NatureLifeMatterChance

About this quote

What does it mean?
The arrangement of matter naturally leads to forms like trees or animals; the miracle would be if nothing resulted.
In plain terms
Nature follows logical patterns so specific forms are expected given the right conditions.
What can you take from it?
Complex life arises naturally from the right arrangement of matter.

Where it applies

  • debating origins of life
  • discussing chance vs design
  • scientific speculation

Putting it to work

  • study material conditions
  • look for natural patterns

Questions to consider

  • Is life a miracle or a necessity?
  • How does form arise from matter?

Another view

The argument assumes matter behaves predictably without intent.

More from Cyrano de Bergerac

  1. I will prove that there are infinite worlds in an infinite world. Imagine the universe as a great animal, and the stars as worlds like other animals inside it.…

    Permalink to quote #42
  2. You are amazed that matter can form a man when matter is all mixed up at random and so many things go into making a person. But do you not realize that before …

    Permalink to quote #44
  3. I signaled to my host to try to have the philosophers expound on some aspect of their knowledge. As a good friend he immediately rose to the occasion. I won't …

    Permalink to quote #41

Related quotes

  1. I figure I've done what I could do, more or less, and now I'm going back to being a chemical; all we are is a lot of talking nitrogen, you know...

    Arthur MillerArthur Miller quote #30
  2. You are amazed that matter can form a man when matter is all mixed up at random and so many things go into making a person. But do you not realize that before …

    Cyrano de BergeracCyrano de Bergerac quote #44
  3. Maybe that's what life is... a wink of the eye and winking stars.

    Jack KerouacJack Kerouac quote #1