Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
Opera plots can be excellent while the music remains poor. Separate story from composition in critique.
In plain terms
Good stories do not guarantee good music.
What can you take from it?
Judge music and libretto separately.

Where it applies

  • music review
  • performance critique
  • art discussion

Putting it to work

  • separate lyrics from melody
  • evaluate music independently
  • be specific

Questions to consider

  • Can good story save bad music?
  • How do you rank artistic elements?

Another view

Some works succeed only through synthesis of elements.

More from Dmitri Shostakovich

  1. You ask if I would have been different without 'Party guidance'? Yes, almost certainly. No doubt the line I was pursuing when I wrote the Fourth Symphony would…

    Permalink to quote #11
  2. It's about the people, who have stopped believing because the cup of evil has run over.

    Permalink to quote #13
  3. The real geniuses know where their writing has to be good and where they can get away with some mediocrity.

    Permalink to quote #10

Related quotes

  1. Wagner has great moments but dull quarter hours - Rossini

    Richard WagnerRichard Wagner quote #18
  2. Ever since I was a little boy, I would study composition. And it was Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky that influenced me the most. If you take an album like Nutcracker…

    Michael JacksonMichael Jackson quote #23
  3. Aerial succeeds because it's all there for a reason. And because the good stuff is just so sublime. 'King of the Mountain', Bush's Elvis-inspired single, is bo…

    Kate BushKate Bush quote #326