Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
Gershwin criticizes his own work as disjointed, acknowledging his talent for melody but questioning his skills as a composer.
In plain terms
I write good melodies but not good compositions.
What can you take from it?
Self-criticism is vital for growth.

Where it applies

  • creative work
  • peer review
  • self-evaluation

Putting it to work

  • improving craft
  • honest critique
  • teaching

Questions to consider

  • How do you judge your work?
  • Is melody enough?

Another view

It is highly subjective self-assessment.

More from George Gershwin

  1. It was on the train,with its rattle-ty bang,that is often so stimulating to a composer that I suddenly heard the complete construction of the Rhapsody. Comment…

    Permalink to quote #12
  2. Gershwin's tragedy was not that he failed to cross the tracks, but rather that he did, and once there in his new habitat, was deprived of the chance to plunge …

    Permalink to quote #14
  3. I like to think of music as an emotional science.

    Permalink to quote #11

Related quotes

  1. I am now satisfied that the future music of this country must be founded upon what are called negro melodies. This must be the real foundation of any serious a…

    Antonin DvorakAntonin Dvorak quote #1
  2. Asked if he had ever conducted any Stockhausen, he said, 'No, but I once trod in some.'

    Thomas BeechamThomas Beecham quote #2
  3. With Moondance, I wrote the melody first. I played the melody on a soprano sax and I knew I had a song so I wrote lyrics to go with the melody. That's the way …

    Van MorrisonVan Morrison quote #2