Skip to content
quotesby

If sin must be kept alive, then hell must be kept alive; but while I regard the smallest sin as infinitely loathsome, I do not believe that any being, never good enough to see the essential ugliness of sin, could sin so as to deserve such punishment. I am not now, however, dealing with the question of the duration of punishment, but with the idea of punishment itself; and would only say in passing, that the notion that a creature born imperfect, nay, born with impulses to evil not of his own generating, and which he could not help having, a creature to whom the true face of God was never presented, and by whom it never could have been seen, should be thus condemned, is as loathsome a lie against God as could find place in heart too undeveloped to understand what justice is, and too low to look up into the face of Jesus.

George MacDonald#20

MoralityJusticeMercyPunishmentSinTheology

About this quote

What does it mean?
MacDonald argues that condemning imperfect beings to eternal punishment without proper knowledge of good and evil is unjust and un-Godly.
In plain terms
It is wrong to punish people for sins if they were not born perfect or taught right from wrong.
What can you take from it?
Punishment should consider a person's capacity to understand and choose.

Where it applies

  • theological debate
  • moral judgment
  • spiritual counsel

Putting it to work

  • ethical reasoning
  • theological discussion
  • pastoral care

Questions to consider

  • What makes punishment just?
  • Is it fair to judge without full knowledge?

Another view

It challenges traditional doctrines of eternal punishment without offering alternatives.

More from George MacDonald

  1. A genuine work of art must mean many things; the truer its art, the more things it will mean. If my drawing, on the other hand, is so far from being a work of …

    Permalink to quote #19
  2. Afflictions are but the shadows of God's wings.

    Permalink to quote #21
  3. After a few days, Willie got tired of [the water-wheel] - and no blame to him, for it was no earthly use beyond amusement, and that which can only amuse can ne…

    Permalink to quote #18

Related quotes

  1. A God all mercy is a God unjust.

    Edward YoungEdward Young quote #52
  2. Allah's Apostle [=Muhammad] said, 'The deeds of anyone of you will not save you (from the (Hell) Fire).' They said, 'Even you (will not be saved by your deeds)…

    Holy Prophet MuhammadHoly Prophet Muhammad quote #2
  3. The damned are in the abyss of Hell, as within a woeful city, where they suffer unspeakable torments, in all their senses and members, because as they have emp…

    Francis de SalesFrancis de Sales quote #3