Let me explain a little: Certain things are bad so far as they go, such as pain, and no one, not even a lunatic, calls a tooth-ache good in itself; but a knife which cuts clumsily and with difficulty is called a bad knife, which it certainly is not. It is only not so good as other knives to which men have grown accustomed. A knife is never bad except on such rare occasions as that in which it is neatly and scientifically planted in the middle of one's back. The coarsest and bluntest knife which ever broke a pencil into pieces instead of sharpening it is a good thing in so far as it is a knife. It would have appeared a miracle in the Stone Age. What we call a bad knife is a good knife not good enough for us; what we call a bad hat is a good hat not good enough for us; what we call bad cookery is good cookery not good enough for us; what we call a bad civilization is a good civilization not good enough for us. We choose to call the great mass of the history of mankind bad, not because it is bad, but because we are better. This is palpably an unfair principle. Ivory may not be so white as snow, but the whole Arctic continent does not make ivory black.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Things called bad are often just not good enough for us. They are still good in themselves if they function.
- In plain terms
- A bad knife is still a knife, just not a good one.
- What can you take from it?
- Judge things by function, not perfection.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When do you mistake 'not perfect' for 'bad'?
- What is truly useless?
Another view
Some things are truly broken beyond any functional use.
More from Gilbert Keith Chesterton
Every one of the great revolutionists, from Isaiah to Shelley, have been optimists. They have been indignant, not about the badness of existence, but about the…
Permalink to quote #52 Now it has appeared to me unfair that humanity should be engaged perpetually in calling all those things bad which have been good enough to make other things b…
Permalink to quote #54 The pessimist is commonly spoken of as the man in revolt. He is not. Firstly, because it requires some cheerfulness to continue in revolt, and secondly, becaus…
Permalink to quote #51
Related quotes
Earth's noblest thing,-a woman perfected.
James Russell LowellJames Russell Lowell quote #1 If a meaningless person says something is meaningless, that's probably proof that it isn't meaningless; and if a boring person says something is boring, that's…
Akira KurosawaAkira Kurosawa quote #6 The universe may be as great as they say. But it wouldn't be missed if it didn't exist.
Piet HeinPiet Hein quote #16