I wish to deal with my most distinguished contemporaries, not personally or in a merely literary manner, but in relation to the real body of doctrine which they teach. I am not concerned with Mr. Rudyard Kipling as a vivid artist or a vigorous personality; I am concerned with him as a Heretic - that is to say, a man whose view of things has the hardihood to differ from mine. I am not concerned with Mr. Bernard Shaw as one of the most brilliant and one of the most honest men alive; I am concerned with him as a Heretic - that is to say, a man whose philosophy is quite solid, quite coherent, and quite wrong.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The author evaluates contemporaries based on their conflicting doctrines rather than their artistic or personal traits.
- In plain terms
- I judge people by their wrong ideas, not their talent or character.
- What can you take from it?
- Engage with ideas and doctrines, not just personality or style.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Do you judge ideas by their correctness or their coherence?
- Is it fair to ignore an author's personality?
Another view
This view risks dismissing valuable artistic contributions due to ideological disagreements.
More from Gilbert Keith Chesterton
When everything about a people is for the time growing weak and ineffective, it begins to talk about efficiency. So it is that when a man's body is a wreck he …
Permalink to quote #75 As enunciated today, 'progress' is simply a comparative of which we have not settled the superlative.
Permalink to quote #77 There are some people, nevertheless - and I am one of them - who think that the most practical and important thing about a man is still his view of the univers…
Permalink to quote #74
Related quotes
The doctrine of the divinity of Jesus is made a convenient cover for absurdity.
John AdamsJohn Adams quote #99 Nietzsche was stupid and abnormal.
Leo TolstoyLeo Tolstoy quote #122 'Most of the failings of Objectivism all pertain directly or indirectly to issues of psychology.'[1]
Nathaniel BrandenNathaniel Branden quote #1