Skip to content
quotesby

The truth seems to be, that like many other geniuses, this Man of Mosses takes great delight in hoodwinking the world,-at least, with respect to himself. Personally, I doubt not, that he rather prefers to be generally esteemed but a so-so sort of author; being willing to reserve the thorough and acute appreciation of what he is, to that party most qualified to judge-that is, to himself. Besides, at the bottom of their natures, men like Hawthorne, in many things, deem the plaudits of the public such strong presumptive evidence of mediocrity in the object of them, that it would in some degree render them doubtful of their own powers, did they hear much and vociferous braying concerning them in the public

Herman Melville#23

AuthorsCriticismGeniusPraiseReputation

About this quote

What does it mean?
Melville defends Nathaniel Hawthorne, suggesting the author prefers private judgment over public acclaim. He claims geniuses often see public praise as a sign of mediocrity.
In plain terms
Geniuses like Hawthorne prefer private respect over loud public praise, which they see as suspicious.
What can you take from it?
Understand that true creators may distrust loud public praise.

Where it applies

  • artistic criticism
  • author interviews

Putting it to work

  • value private critique over public noise
  • distrust excessive praise

Questions to consider

  • Is public praise a sign of mediocrity?
  • How do artists seek validation?

Another view

This view may overgeneralize; many artists do value public recognition.

More from Herman Melville

  1. I found that but to glean after this man, is better than to be in at the harvest of others.

    Permalink to quote #22
  2. It is hard to be finite upon an infinite subject, and all subjects are infinite.

    Permalink to quote #24
  3. Genius, all over the world, stands hand in hand, and one shock of recognition runs the whole circle round.

    Permalink to quote #21

Related quotes

  1. I look upon Upton Sinclair as one of the greatest novelists in the world, the Zola of America.

    Upton SinclairUpton Sinclair quote #34
  2. A practitioner in panegyric, or, to speak more plainly, a professor of the art of puffing.

    Richard Brinsley SheridanRichard Brinsley Sheridan quote #34
  3. The full, the monstrous demonstration that Tennyson was not Tennysonian.

    Henry JamesHenry James quote #43