Skip to content
quotesby

Scholarship has yielded to the irresistible pull that science exerts on our minds by its self-confidence and the promise of certified knowledge. But, to repeat, the objects of culture are not analyzable, not graspable by the geometric mind. Great works of art are great by virtue of being syntheses of the world; they qualify as art by fusing form and contents into an indivisible whole; what they offer is not 'discourse about,' nor a cipher to be decoded, but a prolonged incitement to finesse. So it is paradoxical that our way of introducing young minds to such works should be the way of scholarship.

Jacques Barzun#33

CultureEducationArtScienceAnalysisScholarship

About this quote

What does it mean?
Scholarship often tries to analyze art scientifically but art resists this, offering instead a call to finesse and synthesis.
In plain terms
Science tries to analyze art but art resists analysis and offers finesse instead.
What can you take from it?
Art should be experienced, not just analyzed as data.

Where it applies

  • teaching art
  • academic research
  • appreciating culture

Putting it to work

  • experience art directly
  • value synthesis over analysis
  • teach finesse

Questions to consider

  • How should we teach art?
  • Is analysis ever useful for art?

Another view

Scholarship can also provide necessary context for understanding art.

More from Jacques Barzun

  1. Philosophers no longer write for the intelligent, only for their fellow professionals. The few thousand academic philosophers in the world do not stint themsel…

    Permalink to quote #32
  2. Criticism will need an injection of humility - that is, a recognition of its role as ancillary to the arts, needed only occasionally in a temporary capacity. S…

    Permalink to quote #34
  3. On the one hand, society needs a common faith and vigorous institutions with the power to coerce; and on the other, the individual as a human soul or as the be…

    Permalink to quote #31

Related quotes

  1. Is no one inspired by our present picture of the universe? This value of science remains unsung by singers, you are reduced to hearing not a song or poem, but …

    Richard FeynmanRichard Feynman quote #47
  2. Art hath an enemy called Ignorance.

    Ben JonsonBen Jonson quote #1
  3. Without books, God is silent, justice dormant, natural science at a stand, philosophy lame, letters dumb, and all things involved in darkness.

    Thomas V. BartholinThomas V. Bartholin quote #1