Bohr had... discovered that the frequencies corresponding to very large integers could be calculated accurately from the classical mechanics; they were simply the number of times that an ordinary electron would complete the circuit of its orbit in one second when it was at a very great distance from the nucleus of the atom to which it belonged. This could only mean that when an electron receded to a great distance from the nucleus of its atom, it not only assumed the properties of an ordinary electron, but also behaved as directed by the classical mechanics. Yet the classical mechanics failed completely for the calculation of frequencies corresponding to small orbits.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Classical mechanics works for large electron orbits but fails for small ones, showing where limits lie.
- In plain terms
- Old physics works when electrons are far from the nucleus but not when they are close.
- What can you take from it?
- Know where classical rules stop working in atomic systems.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Where does classical physics fail exactly?
- How do we find the boundary of a theory?
Another view
The quote assumes classical mechanics applies at all large distances which may not be exact.
More from James Jeans
Heisenberg now approached the problem from a new philosophical angle. He discarded all models, pictures and parables, and made a clear distinction between sure…
Permalink to quote #31 A similar situation occurred in astronomy, where the Newtonian law of gravitation had been found to predict the orbits of the outer planets with great accuracy…
Permalink to quote #33 Bohr's investigation had typified what had become a standard procedure in problems of theoretical physics. The first step was to discover the mathematical laws…
Permalink to quote #30
Related quotes
The theory community, myself included - became rather troubled about the particle.
Bob JaffeBob Jaffe quote #1 Physics has entered a remarkable era. Ideas that were once the realm of science fiction are now entering our theoretical - and maybe even experimental - grasp.…
Lisa RandallLisa Randall quote #2 Our understanding of the four basic concepts of Physics -- space, time, matter and force -- has undergone radical change in the course of work on unification, …
Peter FreundPeter Freund quote #2