Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author criticizes a book for confusingly setting an alien planet like the Canadian province Manitoba.
In plain terms
The book is bad because the planet is like Manitoba.
What can you take from it?
Avoid confusing your setting with real places.

Where it applies

  • writing fiction
  • reviewing sci-fi
  • worldbuilding

Putting it to work

  • keep settings distinct
  • avoid real world confusion
  • critique sci-fi

Questions to consider

  • How much is too much in worldbuilding?
  • Should aliens look like real places?

Another view

Using real places as inspiration for alien worlds is a common trope.

More from James Nicoll

  1. John Barnes is incredibly variable. Pete's Rule (Never buy a Barnes with sodomy in it) is a good one but unfortunately the publisher does not put that kind of …

    Permalink to quote #9
  2. I have hated every Kress I read, especially this one, but the Bear is a standard Bear and if you like this sort of thing, this is the sort of thing you'll like.

    Permalink to quote #11
  3. Before it exploded one night, I went to a four grade, two room schoolhouse and we had textbooks from the 1940s.

    Permalink to quote #8

Related quotes

  1. The best of our fiction is by novelists who allow that it is as good as they can give, and the worst by novelists who maintain that they could do much better i…

    J. M. BarrieJ. M. Barrie quote #1
  2. I regard criticism as an art, and if in this country and in this age it is practiced with honesty, it is no more remunerative than the work of an avant-garde f…

    Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #1
  3. IF - and the thing is wildly possible - the charge of writing nonsense were ever brought against the author of this brief but instructive poem, it would be bas…

    Lewis CarrollLewis Carroll quote #2