Skip to content
quotesby

This is the sort of book that justifies fatwahs. If WWIII occurred right now, we could die happy knowing Baxter would never write again. If a dinosaur killing asteroid was headed for Earth and I knew Baxter had another book coming up, I would campaign for letting the rock hit, since it is obviously the work of a benovelent deity trying to save us from another Titan.

James Nicoll#4

LiteratureExtremismFreedomMediaPoliticsViolence

About this quote

What does it mean?
The reviewer suggests the book justifies extremist actions and would be welcome if it never appeared again.
In plain terms
The book is seen as dangerous enough to wish its author dead.
What can you take from it?
Extreme dislike can lead to extreme rhetoric.

Where it applies

  • online debates
  • discussing radicalization

Putting it to work

  • boycotting
  • public condemnation

Questions to consider

  • When does criticism become hate?
  • How should we handle offensive works?

Another view

The statement is exaggerated and promotes hostility.

More from James Nicoll

  1. [F]olks would better off dipping their heads in a bucket of liquid [nitrogen] and battering them against a tree very very hard than reading Baxter's Titan. It …

    Permalink to quote #3
  2. I can't help but notice that everytime I fly somewhere, other people's planes fall out of the sky.

    Permalink to quote #5
  3. Romeo and Juliet *died*. I always liked that in a teen romance story.

    Permalink to quote #2

Related quotes

  1. You can choose whatever name you like for the two types of government. I personally call the type of government which can be removed without ?violence 'democra…

    Karl PopperKarl Popper quote #1
  2. 'They say they blame it on a song when someone kills a cop, what music did they listen to when they bombed Iraq?'

    Michael FrantiMichael Franti quote #2
  3. I would remind you that extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice! And let me remind you also that moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue!

    Barry GoldwaterBarry Goldwater quote #3