Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
Lowell praises Poe's talent but heavily critiques his work as being part nonsense, using a playful, dismissive tone.
In plain terms
He admits Poe is talented but says much of his work is nonsense.
What can you take from it?
Great talent does not guarantee quality in all work.

Where it applies

  • literary discussion
  • book review
  • critique

Putting it to work

  • evaluate writers fairly
  • distinguish style from substance

Questions to consider

  • How do you judge an author?
  • Does talent excuse poor work?

Another view

The opinion is harsh and reflects personal bias rather than objective critique.

More from James Russell Lowell

  1. And I honor the man who is willing to sink Half his present repute for the freedom to think, And, when he has thought, be his cause strong or weak, Will risk t…

    Permalink to quote #50
  2. For though he builds glorious temples, 'tis odd He leaves never a doorway to get in a god.

    Permalink to quote #52
  3. In creating, the only hard thing's to begin; A grass-blade's no easier to make than an oak, If you've once found the way you've achieved the grand stroke.

    Permalink to quote #49

Related quotes

  1. If there were only some mechanism (like Seurat's proposed system of painting, or the projected Universal Algebra that Godel believes Leibnitz to have perfected…

    Randall JarrellRandall Jarrell quote #2
  2. In my opinion Mr. Moore is a greater poet than Mr. Yeats. He has lived obscurely, and has not displayed Mr. Yeats's talent for self-dramatization; for these re…

    Thomas Sturge MooreThomas Sturge Moore quote #5
  3. Critics search for ages for the wrong word, which, to give them credit, they eventually find.

    Peter UstinovPeter Ustinov quote #11