Skip to content
quotesby

I feel outside all the contending sections of the liberal party-for I am not in favour of home rule, or the creation of a Dublin parliament...I cannot consent to a measure which is so offensive to the whole protestant population of Ireland, and to the whole sentiment of the province of Ulster so far as its loyal and protestant people are concerned. I cannot agree to exclude them from the protection of the imperial parliament. ...In any case of a division, it is I suppose certain that a considerable majority of British members will oppose the bill. Thus, whilst it will have the support of the rebel members, it will be opposed by a majority from Great Britain and by a most hostile vote from all that is loyal in Ireland. The result will be, if a majority supports you it will be one composed in effect of the men who for six years past have insulted the Queen, have torn down the national flag, have declared your lord lieutenant guilty of deliberate murder, and have made the imperial parliament an assembly totally unable to manage the legislative business for which it annually assembles at Westminster.

John Bright#6

PoliticsNationalismParliamentRightsSovereignty

About this quote

What does it mean?
The speaker opposes home rule for Ireland due to unionist concerns.
In plain terms
He rejects creating an Irish parliament because it harms Protestants in Ulster.
What can you take from it?
Political changes must consider minority rights.

Where it applies

  • legislative debates
  • secession talks
  • constitutional reform

Putting it to work

  • legislation
  • negotiation
  • compromise

Questions to consider

  • How do we balance majorities and minorities?
  • What defines loyalty?

Another view

Opponents argue independence is worth the risk.

More from John Bright

  1. Force is no remedy.

    Permalink to quote #5
  2. Had they been in the wilderness they would have complained of the Ten Commandments.

    Permalink to quote #7
  3. The right honorable gentleman is the first of the new party who has retired into his political cave of Adullam and he has called about him everyone that was in…

    Permalink to quote #4

Related quotes

  1. Those who try to give us advice on matters of human rights do nothing but provoke an ironic smile among us. We will not permit anyone to interfere in our affai…

    Konstantin ChernenkoKonstantin Chernenko quote #1
  2. Don't be surprised if I demur, for, be advised My passport's green. No glass of ours was ever raised To toast The Queen.

    Seamus HeaneySeamus Heaney quote #5
  3. Our sole aim was, by virtue of this war, to rid ourselves of the lot of them, however many international decisions there were. Each one represented a blow to o…

    Ahmed DjemalAhmed Djemal quote #6