Skip to content
quotesby

Civilisation knows how to use such powers as it has, while the immense potentiality of the unlicensed is dissipated in vapour. Civilisation wins because it is a world-wide league; its enemies fail because they are parochial. But supposing ... supposing anarchy learned from civilisation and became international. Oh, I don't mean the bands of advertising donkeys who call themselves International Unions of Workers and suchlike rubbish. I mean if the real brain-stuff of the world were internationalised. Suppose that the links in the cordon of civilisation were neutralised by other links in a far more potent chain. The earth is seething with incoherent power and unorganised intelligence.

John Buchan#43

SocietyPoliticsPowerCivilizationWarOrganizationChaos

About this quote

What does it mean?
Civilization succeeds through global organization, while chaos fails due to lack of coordination; this dynamic changes if chaos becomes international.
In plain terms
Organization beats chaos because it is global, but chaos could win if it became organized too.
What can you take from it?
Global organization wins over isolated power, but coordinated chaos could change that.

Where it applies

  • global politics
  • organizational strategy
  • social movements

Putting it to work

  • build coalitions
  • organize broadly
  • avoid fragmentation

Questions to consider

  • How does organization protect civilization?
  • What would coordinated chaos look like?

Another view

International coordination of destructive forces is a real and present risk.

More from John Buchan

  1. If those extra-social brains are so potent, why after all do they effect so little? A dull police-officer, with the machine behind him, can afford to laugh at …

    Permalink to quote #42
  2. 'It would scarcely be destruction,' he replied gently. 'Let us call it iconoclasm, the swallowing of formulas, which has always had its full retinue of idealis…

    Permalink to quote #44
  3. I cannot pry into motives. I only know of the existence of great extra-social intelligences. Let us say that they distrust the machine. They may be idealists a…

    Permalink to quote #41

Related quotes

  1. Imagine that leader of all the enemy, in that great plain of Babylon, sitting on a sort of throne of smoking flame, a horrible and terrifying sight. Watch him …

    Ignatius of LoyolaIgnatius of Loyola quote #4
  2. People rarely win wars; governments rarely lose them.

    Arundhati RoyArundhati Roy quote #14
  3. All political arrangements, in that they have to bring a variety of widely-discordant interests into unity and harmony, necessarily occasion manifold collision…

    Wilhelm von HumboldtWilhelm von Humboldt quote #15