Skip to content
quotesby

With all the efforts now to disassociate President Bush from conservatism, I am starting to believe that conservatism itself - not the political machine, mind you, but the ideology - is heading toward that misty land-over-the-ocean where ideologies go after they've shuffled off this mortal coil. Sort of like the way post-Stalinist lefties used to say, 'You can't say Communism's failed. It's just never really been tried.' But as it was with Communism, so with conservatism. When all the people who call themselves conservatives get together and run the government, they're on the line for it. Conservative president. Conservative House. Conservative Senate. What we appear to be in for now is the emergence of this phantom conservatism existing out in the ether, wholly cut loose from any connection to the actual people who are universally identified as the conservatives and who claim the label for themselves. We can even go a bit beyond this though. The big claim now is that President Bush isn't a conservative because he hasn't shrunk the size of government and he's a reckless deficit spender. But let's be honest: Balanced budgets and shrinking the size of government hasn't been part of conservatism - or to be more precise, Movement Conservatism - for going on thirty years. The conservative movement and the Republican party are the movement and party of deficit spending. And neither has any claim to any real association with limited or small government. Just isn't borne out by any factual record or political agenda. Not in the Reagan presidency, the Bush presidency or the second Bush presidency. The intervening period of fiscal restraint comes under Clinton.

Joshua Micah Marshall#5

PoliticsPowerBeliefConsistencyIdeology

About this quote

What does it mean?
Ideologies may lose meaning when their adherents fail to live up to their principles in power.
In plain terms
Conservatism might be dead if conservatives don't follow its ideas.
What can you take from it?
Ideas die when practitioners ignore them.

Where it applies

  • governance
  • party leadership

Putting it to work

  • accountability
  • introspection

Questions to consider

  • Can an ideology survive failure?
  • What defines a true believer?

Another view

Ideologies can evolve instead of dying.

More from Joshua Micah Marshall

  1. To the president the Democrats should be saying, Double or Nothing is Not a Foreign Policy. The great bulk of the public doesn't believe this president any mor…

    Permalink to quote #4
  2. There's this old line the wise folks in Washington have that 'it's not the crime, but the cover-up.' But only fools believe that. It's always about the crime. …

    Permalink to quote #6
  3. If you think back to the Swift Boat debacle of 2004, the surface issue was John Kerry's honesty and bravery as a sailor in Vietnam. Far more powerful, however,…

    Permalink to quote #3

Related quotes

  1. At that time I believed in the Fuhrer principle because to me it meant that the best one should be the leader. If the leader is good and responsible, then the …

    Walther FunkWalther Funk quote #1
  2. If those in charge of our society - politicians, corporate executives, and owners of press and television - can dominate our ideas, they will be secure in thei…

    Howard ZinnHoward Zinn quote #1
  3. What does Christianity mean today? National Socialism is a religion. All we lack is a religious genius capable of uprooting outmoded religious practices and pu…

    Joseph GoebbelsJoseph Goebbels quote #2