Skip to content
quotesby

I think yet again of my father, who struggled to become a painter after he was forced into early and unwelcome retirement by the Great Depression. He has reason to be optimistic about his new career, since the early stages of his pictures, whether still or portraits or landscapes, were full of pow. Mother, meaning to be helpful, would say of each one: 'That's really wonderful, Kurt. Now all you have to do is finish it.' He would then ruin it. I remember a portrait he did of his only brother, Alex, who was an insurance salesman, which he called 'Special Agent'. When he roughed it in, his hand and eye conspired with a few bold strokes to capture several important truths about Alex, including a hint of disappointment. Uncle Alex was a proud graduate of Harvard, who would rather have been a scholar of literature than an insurance man. When Father finished the portrait, made sure every square inch of masonite had its share of paint, Uncle Alex had disappeared entirely. We had a drunk and lustful Queen Victoria instead. This was terrible.

Kurt Vonnegut#158

ArtCreativityFamilyFailure

About this quote

What does it mean?
Vonnegut recalls his father's struggle with painting, where early promise was ruined by finishing work, and his mother's well-meaning but damaging praise.
In plain terms
His father painted well at first but ruined work when finishing it, despite mother's praise.
What can you take from it?
Encouragement can sometimes hinder completion if it pressures too much.

Where it applies

  • art education
  • family dynamics
  • career advice

Putting it to work

  • balancing praise with realism
  • supporting artistic completion

Questions to consider

  • How do parents affect creativity?
  • Why do artists stop mid-way?

Another view

The father may have ruined work due to self-criticism not maternal praise.

More from Kurt Vonnegut

  1. During my three years in Vietnam, I certainly heard plenty of last words by dying American footsoldiers. Not one of them, however, had illusions that he had so…

    Permalink to quote #157
  2. I don't care if I'm remembered or not when I'm dead. (A scientist I knew at General Electric, who was married to a woman named Josephine, said to me, 'Why shou…

    Permalink to quote #159
  3. Another flaw in the human character is that everybody wants to build and nobody wants to do maintenance.

    Permalink to quote #156

Related quotes

  1. I like the idea that I can make a drawing or I can make a painting or I can write notes, write my sort of journal thing, and someday my kid will have that. (19…

    Johnny DeppJohnny Depp quote #16
  2. I was raised around a lot of artists, musicians, photographers, painters and people that were in theatre. Just having the art-communal hippie experience as a c…

    Jared LetoJared Leto quote #47
  3. What the artist wishes to do - as far as you are concerned - is to take you out of yourself. As far as he is concerned, he wishes to express himself.

    Ford Madox FordFord Madox Ford quote #1