[The] contention that today's rich person is simply the winner of a 'race that is open for anyone to enter' takes no account of inheritance or how we are equipped as we enter that race. It doesn't acknowledge that some approach the starting line in streamlined Lycra suits and track shoes, with full knowledge of the rules, a determined attitude and belief in their own abilities, not to mention a close friendship with those setting the rules and choosing the winner. Others, hungry from not having had a meal that day, barely make it to the starting line, don't really understand the purpose of the race or its rules, lack self-confidence and are full of hostility, and are convinced that those officials at the side of the track are actually cops waiting to bust them.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The idea that success is purely meritocratic ignores inherited advantages and systemic barriers.
- In plain terms
- Success is not fair because some start with more advantages than others.
- What can you take from it?
- Meritocracy ignores unequal starting points.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How much does your background determine your success?
Another view
Some argue personal effort still matters regardless of starting conditions.
More from Linda McQuaig
[W]e are assured not just that things will work out over time, but that scarcity is 'vanishing before our eyes.' Why, look - even as we watch - those 2.8 billi…
Permalink to quote #16 [W]e have things fundamentally backwards today: we let the needs of the economy dictate the nature of our society, while we should let the needs of our society…
Permalink to quote #18 It is almost enough to make one's jaw drop to think that officials at the World Bank and the IMF would suggest that they have poverty alleviation in mind when …
Permalink to quote #15
Related quotes
The Bush Administration do have moral values. Their moral values are very explicit: shine the boots of the rich and the powerful, kick everybody else in the fa…
Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #19 It's more a symptom of increasing class and income differentiation. The ultra-rich may be feeding roses and champagne to their racehorses, but that doesn't mea…
Bruce SterlingBruce Sterling quote #39 I'm acquainted with a, uh, gentleman who claims that the extent to which a society focuses on the needs of its lowest common denominator is the extent to which…
Tom RobbinsTom Robbins quote #99