We properly judge a critic's virtue not by his freedom from error but by the nature of the mistakes he does make, for he makes them, if he is worth reading, because he has in mind something besides his perceptions about art in itself - he has in mind the demands that he makes upon life.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- A critic's worth is shown by the nature of their mistakes, reflecting their deeper demands on life.
- In plain terms
- Good critics make meaningful mistakes based on life values.
- What can you take from it?
- Judge critics by their values not just accuracy.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What makes a critic valuable?
- How do mistakes reveal values?
Another view
Accuracy is still important in criticism.
More from Lionel Trilling
Even the nonreligious may exercise aesthetic judgment in matters of religion, and indeed our age has given the unbelieving a sophisticated taste in religious l…
Permalink to quote #17 We are all ill; but even a universal sickness implies an idea of health.
Permalink to quote #19 Disgust is expressed by violence, and it is to be noted of our intellectual temper that violence is a quality which is felt to have a peculiarly intellectual s…
Permalink to quote #16
Related quotes
Atheists and the unchurched undervalue the extent to which they are getting a free ride on the social strength that religious-based virtue provides.
Daniel HenningerDaniel Henninger quote #1 The secret story is the one we'll never know, although we're living it from day to day, thinking we're alive, thinking we've got it all under control and the s…
Roberto BolanoRoberto Bolano quote #1 I believe that any 'awareness' of life is 'spiritual' since awareness can only be a quality of the spirit not of the material world or of matter and machines. …
Chick CoreaChick Corea quote #1