Skip to content
quotesby

The Porte, acting under the same obligation, and wishing to secure the safety of its army and its citizens, took energetic measures to check these uprisings. The deportation of the Armenians was one of these preventive measures. I admit also that the deportation was not carried out lawfully everywhere. In some places unlawful acts were committed. The already existing hatred among the Armenians and Mohammedans, intensified by the barbarous activities of the former, had created many tragic consequences. Some of the officials abused their authority, and in many places people took preventive measures into their own hands and innocent people were molested. I confess it. I confess, also, that the duty of the Government was to prevent these abuses and atrocities, or at least to hunt down and punish their perpetrators severely. In many places, where the property and goods of the deported people were looted, and the Armenians molested, we did arrest those who were responsible and punished them according to the law. I confess, however, that we ought to have acted more sternly, opened up a general investigation for the purpose of finding out all the promoters and looters and punished them severely.

Mehmed Talat#5

HistoryHuman rightsLawResponsibility

About this quote

What does it mean?
The speaker admits deportations were sometimes unlawful, blaming mutual hatred and claiming the government should punish abuses.
In plain terms
Deportations were partly unlawful; the government should punish the perpetrators.
What can you take from it?
Even perpetrators perpetrators acknowledge legal violations and call for accountability.

Where it applies

  • state‑organized displacement
  • post‑conflict reconciliation

Putting it to work

  • investigate abuses
  • hold officials accountable

Questions to consider

  • Can partial admissions lead to genuine justice?
  • What mechanisms ensure accountability for mass deportations?

Another view

Admission of wrongdoing does not mitigate the scale of harm.

More from Mehmed Talat

  1. The Turkish elements here referred to were shortsighted, fanatical, and yet sincere in their belief. The public encouraged them, and they had the general appro…

    Permalink to quote #4
  2. We need to tranquilize our neighbors. State officials ought to remain in ignorance. Let the Armenians wait, opportunities will certainly come our way too. Turk…

    Permalink to quote #6
  3. What on earth do you want? The question is settled. There are no more Armenians.

    Permalink to quote #3

Related quotes

  1. I am an Iranian. A descendent of Cyrus The Great. The very emperor who proclaimed at the pinnacle of power 2500 years ago that...he would not reign over the pe…

    Shirin EbadiShirin Ebadi quote #1
  2. He is responsible because of the conspiracy and the plots for all that happened to the Jewish people - from the shores of the Arctic Ocean to the Aegean Sea, f…

    Adolf EichmannAdolf Eichmann quote #24
  3. Slaves cannot breathe in England; if their lungs Receive our air, that moment they are free! They touch our country, and their shackles fall.

    William CowperWilliam Cowper quote #67