Skip to content
quotesby

The division of the seamless garment of Christendom into separate nations or sovereign states, which today we accept as a matter of course, was then only beginning. And the idea that people belong to all sorts of different races, with boasts of racial 'purity' or 'superiority', is something that has come up practically within the memories of people still alive. Hence if the astronomer had been asked concerning his race and nation, he might have replied that he was a loyal son of the Church[1], but otherwise would scarcely have understood the questions. Even for us today it is not an easy question to answer. Torun was founded by Germans; its leading citizens, like those of Cracow, were mostly Germans. Hence the astronomer may well have been of German extraction.[2] The possible connection of the family on both sides with Silesia does not prove much either way for its population was a mixed one. On the other hand, the ancestors, especially on the father's side, must have lived for so many generations under allegiance to the King of Poland as to be, for all practical purposes, Poles. And Copernicus followed the family tradition in siding with the Poles against the Germans in times of crisis. In any case, it was Poland, and Cracow above all, that first nourished the youthful genius of Copernicus. And since his death it is chiefly the Poles who have gloried[3] in their share in him, and have cherished the renown his achievements have brought to their heroic and ill-starred nation.

Nicolaus Copernicus#13

HistoryContextIdentityNationality

About this quote

What does it mean?
Copernicus lived in a time before strict national identities, making his nationality complex.
In plain terms
Nationality was not clear then, so Copernicus was hard to classify.
What can you take from it?
Avoid rigid labels for historical figures.

Where it applies

  • historical debate
  • identity research
  • genealogy

Putting it to work

  • question narrow labels
  • research diverse origins

Questions to consider

  • Does nationality matter for science?
  • How do borders shape identity?

Another view

Some details about identity matter for local context.

More from Nicolaus Copernicus

  1. On the five-hundred-thirtieth anniversary of the birth, and the four-hundred-sixtieth anniversary of the death, of Mikolaj Kopernik, the Senate of the Polish R…

    Permalink to quote #12
  2. Therefore alongside the ancient hypotheses, which are no more probable, let us permit these new hypotheses also to become known, especially since they are admi…

    Permalink to quote #14
  3. Poles and Germans have a common history of great scientists: Today we no longer perceive Copernicus, Hevelius, Schopenhauer and Fahrenheit as the property of o…

    Permalink to quote #11

Related quotes

  1. Men are products, expressions, reflections; they live to the extent that they coincide with their epoch, or to the extent that they differ markedly from it.

    Jose MartiJose Marti quote #9
  2. A colored is a very frightened-to-death Afro-American. A Negro is one that makes it in the system, and he wants to be white. A nigger, he's loud and boisterous…

    James BrownJames Brown quote #1
  3. The Macedonian language is actually an artifact produced for primarily political reasons.

    Vittore PisaniVittore Pisani quote #1