Communism is inequality, but not as property is. Property is the exploitation of the weak by the strong. Communism is the exploitation of the strong by the weak. In property, inequality of conditions is the result of force, under whatever name it be disguised: physical and mental force; force of events, chance, fortune; force of accumulated property, &c. In communism, inequality springs from placing mediocrity on a level with excellence. This damaging equation is repellent to the conscience, and causes merit to complain; for, although it may be the duty of the strong to aid the weak, they prefer to do it out of generosity, - they never will endure a comparison. Give them equal opportunities of labor, and equal wages, but never allow their jealousy to be awakened by mutual suspicion of unfaithfulness in the performance of the common task. Communism is oppression and slavery. Man is very willing to obey the law of duty, serve his country, and oblige his friends; but he wishes to labor when he pleases, where he pleases, and as much as he pleases. He wishes to dispose of his own time, to be governed only by necessity, to choose his friendships, his recreation, and his discipline; to act from judgment, not by command; to sacrifice himself through selfishness, not through servile obligation. Communism is essentially opposed to the free exercise of our faculties, to our noblest desires, to our deepest feelings. Any plan which could be devised for reconciling it with the demands of the individual reason and will would end only in changing the thing while preserving the name. Now, if we are honest truth-seekers, we shall avoid disputes about words. Thus, communism violates the sovereignty of the conscience, and equality: the first, by restricting spontaneity of mind and heart, and freedom of thought and action; the second, by placing labor and laziness, skill and stupidity, and even vice and virtue on an equality in point of comfort. For the rest, if property is impossible on account of the desire to accumulate, communism would soon become so through the desire to shirk.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The author argues property exploits the weak while communism exploits the strong, claiming both are unequal.
- In plain terms
- Property lets the strong take from the weak; communism forces the weak to hold back the strong.
- What can you take from it?
- Evaluate systems for how they treat merit and weakness.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Is equality of outcome fair?
- How should merit be treated?
Another view
The argument assumes merit should always be rewarded equally.
More from P. J. Proudhon
The proprietor, producing neither by his own labor nor by his implement, and receiving products in exchange for nothing, is either a parasite or a thief.
Permalink to quote #12 Before entering upon the subject-matter of these new memoirs, I must explain an hypothesis which will undoubtedly seem strange, but in the absence of which it …
Permalink to quote #14 AXIOM. - Property is the Right of Increase claimed by the Proprietor over any thing which he has stamped as his own.
Permalink to quote #11
Related quotes
The theory of Communism may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property.
Karl MarxKarl Marx quote #31 I believe and I say it is true Democratic feeling, that all the measures of the Government are directed to the purpose of making the rich richer and the poor p…
William Henry HarrisonWilliam Henry Harrison quote #1 Political Freedom without economic equality is a pretense, a fraud, a lie; and the workers want no lying.
Mikhail BakuninMikhail Bakunin quote #3