Skip to content
quotesby

The real searcher after truth will not receive the old because it is old, or reject the new because it is new. He will not believe men because they are dead, or contradict them because they are alive. With him an utterance is worth the truth, the reason it contains, without the slightest regard to the author. He may have been a king or serf - a philosopher or servant, - but the utterance neither gains nor loses in truth or reason. Its value is absolutely independent of the fame or station of the man who gave it to the world.

Robert G. Ingersoll#211

TruthReasonAuthorityKnowledgeIdeasJudgment

About this quote

What does it mean?
Truth should be judged by its content and reason, not by the age or fame of the person who said it. A claim is valuable only if it is sound regardless of who spoke it.
In plain terms
Judge ideas by their truth not by who said them.
What can you take from it?
Evaluate ideas on merit not speaker status.

Where it applies

  • reading ancient texts
  • evaluating new ideas
  • debate

Putting it to work

  • Ignore who said it
  • Focus on logic and evidence

Questions to consider

  • Do you trust experts too much?
  • How do you judge an idea?

Another view

Reputation often signals reliability in everyday decisions.

More from Robert G. Ingersoll

  1. The real marriage is based on mutual affection - the ceremony is but the outward evidence of the inward flame. To this contract there are but two parties. The …

    Permalink to quote #210
  2. The tides and currents of the soul care nothing for the creeds. People who make rules for the conduct of others generally break them themselves. It is so easy …

    Permalink to quote #212
  3. The real marriage - the uniting of hearts, the lighting of the sacred flame in each - is the work of Nature, and it is the best work that nature does. The cere…

    Permalink to quote #209

Related quotes

  1. Reason, it is true, is DICTATOR in the Society of Mankind; from her there ought to lie no Appeal; But here we want a Pope in our Philosophy, to be the infallib…

    Daniel DefoeDaniel Defoe quote #3
  2. Reason, or the ratio of all we have already known, is not the same that it shall be when we know more.

    William BlakeWilliam Blake quote #1
  3. Auctoritas siquidem ex vera ratione processit, ratio vero nequaquam ex auctoritate. Omnis enim auctoritas, quae vera ratione non approbatur, infirma videtur es…

    Johannes Scotus EriugenaJohannes Scotus Eriugena quote #2