Skip to content
quotesby

The truth is, that no one can justly be held responsible for his thoughts. The brain thinks without asking our consent. We believe, or we disbelieve, without an effort of the will. Belief is a result. It is the effect of evidence upon the mind. The scales turn in spite of him who watches. There is no opportunity of being honest or dishonest in the formation of an opinion. The conclusion is entirely independent of desire. We must believe, or we must doubt, in spite of what we wish.

Robert G. Ingersoll#214

BeliefThinkingEvidenceMindOpinionFree will

About this quote

What does it mean?
Belief and thought are involuntary responses to evidence rather than choices of the will. You cannot be blamed for what you genuinely believe because the mind forms opinions independent of desire.
In plain terms
You do not choose your beliefs; they form naturally from what you see and know.
What can you take from it?
Do not blame yourself or others for involuntary beliefs.

Where it applies

  • moral judgment of others
  • self-reflection on bias
  • debate on responsibility

Putting it to work

  • Evaluate arguments on merit not source
  • Avoid blaming people for beliefs

Questions to consider

  • Is belief ever truly voluntary?
  • How do you form your core opinions?

Another view

Some beliefs are actively chosen or reinforced by habit.

More from Robert G. Ingersoll

  1. The true civilization is where every man gives to every other every right that he claims for himself.

    Permalink to quote #213
  2. There are no Gods, no angels, no devils, no heaven or hell. There is only our natural world. Religion is but myth and superstition that hardens the hearts and …

    Permalink to quote #215
  3. The tides and currents of the soul care nothing for the creeds. People who make rules for the conduct of others generally break them themselves. It is so easy …

    Permalink to quote #212

Related quotes

  1. Till their own dreams at length decive 'em, And oft repeating, they believe 'em.

    Matthew PriorMatthew Prior quote #10
  2. O just ones, hear me! You cannot condemn this man, monkey or parrot for saying that the moon is the world he comes from. If he is a man, all men are free. Is h…

    Cyrano de BergeracCyrano de Bergerac quote #37
  3. We shall always keep a spare corner in our heads to give passing hospitality to our friends' opinion.

    Joseph JoubertJoseph Joubert quote #92