Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
Ebert critiques Gladiator for using depression as a substitute for personality, making the film dull despite its action. He argues the characters' bitterness masks a lack of genuine joy or depth.
In plain terms
The movie is dull because the characters are just bitter and miserable instead of interesting.
What can you take from it?
Characters need personality and joy, not just misery, to engage an audience.

Where it applies

  • watching epic films
  • evaluating character arcs
  • reviewing action movies

Putting it to work

  • assess character depth
  • evaluate tone balance
  • identify emotional range

Questions to consider

  • Can a film be engaging without joy?
  • Is depression a valid substitute for personality?

Another view

Dark tones and bitter characters can be effective if handled with artistic intent.

More from Roger Ebert

  1. I know that the real Brockovich liked to dress provocatively; that's her personal style and she's welcome to it. But the Hollywood version makes her look like …

    Permalink to quote #54
  2. It was W. C. Fields who hated to appear in the same scene with a child, a dog, or a plunging neckline - because nobody in the audience would be looking at him.…

    Permalink to quote #56
  3. Since the scenes where they're together are so much less convincing than the ones where they fall apart, watching the movie is like being on a double-date from…

    Permalink to quote #53

Related quotes

  1. We can laugh at comedies like this for two reasons: Because we feel superior to the characters, or because we pity or like them. I do not much like laughing do…

    Roger EbertRoger Ebert quote #46
  2. I think he's a very good technician. And he has something in Psycho, he had some moments. Psycho is one of his most interesting pictures because he had to make…

    Ingmar BergmanIngmar Bergman quote #9
  3. Caligula is sickening, utterly worthless, shameful trash. If it is not the worst film I have ever seen, that makes it all the more shameful: People with talent…

    Roger EbertRoger Ebert quote #14