You should never send an expert to a movie about his specialty. Boxers hate boxing movies. Space buffs said 'Apollo 13' showed the wrong side of the moon. The British believe Mel Gibson's scholarship was faulty in 'Braveheart' merely because some of the key characters hadn't been born at the time of the story. 'Hackers' is, I have no doubt, deeply dubious in the computer science department. While it is no doubt true that in real life no hacker could do what the characters in this movie do, it is no doubt equally true that what hackers can do would not make a very entertaining movie.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Experts often dislike movies about their field because accuracy suffers for entertainment, yet accuracy alone wouldn’t make a good film.
- In plain terms
- Experts hate movies about their job because they aren’t accurate.
- What can you take from it?
- Art needs drama over fact.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Should movies prioritize truth or fun?
Another view
Some genres benefit from factual fidelity.
More from Roger Ebert
I arrive at the end of this review having done my duty as a critic. I have described the movie accurately and you have a good idea what you are in for if you g…
Permalink to quote #68 Most people choose movies that provide exactly what they expect, and tell them things they already know. Others are more curious. We are put on this planet onl…
Permalink to quote #70 I read all the movie reviews, especially those of Ebert, a graceful and witty prose stylist with profound erudition, whose reviews are worth reading just for t…
Permalink to quote #67
Related quotes
Am I really, oh great! They just want to keep that competition going between the two films don't they. But I don't think you can really compare the two. It wil…
Orlando BloomOrlando Bloom quote #6 I want people to go to the movies. I am the man of the spectacle. I'm playing.
Roman PolanskiRoman Polanski quote #11 With Star Wars, George put the butter back into the popcorn.
Steven SpielbergSteven Spielberg quote #16