Skip to content
quotesby

Of course, there is no doubt that if we lived in a police state, it would be easier to catch terrorists. If we lived in a country that allowed the police to search your home at any time for any reason; if we lived in a country that allowed the government to open your mail, eavesdrop on your phone conversations, or intercept your email communications; if we lived in a country that allowed the government to hold people in jail indefinitely based on what they write or think, or based on mere suspicion that they are up to no good, then the government would no doubt discover and arrest more terrorists. But that probably would not be a country in which we would want to live. And that would not be a country for which we could, in good conscience, ask our young people to fight and die. In short, that would not be America.

Russ Feingold#2

PoliticsSecurityCivil libertiesConstitutionTerrorismNational security

About this quote

What does it mean?
Security measures that erase civil liberties may catch more terrorists but create a society not worth defending.
In plain terms
Gaining safety by sacrificing freedom is not a trade worth making.
What can you take from it?
Protect liberty even when seeking security.

Where it applies

  • policy debates
  • legislative votes
  • public discourse

Putting it to work

  • evaluate security bills
  • advocate for safeguards
  • debate tradeoffs

Questions to consider

  • What liberties are non-negotiable?
  • How much safety justifies surveillance?

Another view

Some argue extreme threats justify extreme measures.

More from Russ Feingold

  1. Opening up the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling is bad public policy that has no place in the budget process,. The Budget Committee needs to lea…

    Permalink to quote #1
  2. I will also continue to strongly oppose any reauthorization of the Patriot Act that does not protect the rights and freedoms of law-abiding Americans with no c…

    Permalink to quote #3
  3. Americans want to defeat terrorism and they want the basic character of this country to survive and prosper. They want both security and liberty, and unless we…

    Permalink to quote #4

Related quotes

  1. For six years, the Bush administration has kept America safe from another terrorist attack, allowing the Democrats to claim that the war on terrorism is a frau…

    Ann CoulterAnn Coulter quote #29
  2. The September 11 attacks were major atrocities. In terms of number of victims they do not reach the level of many others, for example, Clinton's bombing of the…

    Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #94
  3. The targeted assassination policy is a correct one. It is inconceivable that terrorists could operate freely without the ground quaking under their feet.

    Amir PeretzAmir Peretz quote #1