Skip to content
quotesby

By committing a crime, a man places himself, of his own accord, outside the chain of eternal obligations which bind every human being to every other one. Punishment alone can weld him back again; fully so, if accompanied by consent on his part; otherwise only partially so. Just as the only way of showing respect for somebody suffering from hunger is to give him something to eat, so the only way of showing respect for somebody who has placed himself outside the law is to reinstate him inside the law by subjecting him to the punishment ordained by law. The need for punishment is not satisfied where, as is generally the case, the penal code is merely a method of exercising pressure through fear. [p.103]

Simone Weil#28

EthicsJusticeCrimeLawObligationPunishment

About this quote

What does it mean?
Crimes break obligations between people; punishment with consent restores them.
In plain terms
Punishment helps restore a person to society if they agree.
What can you take from it?
Punishment should reintegrate offenders.

Where it applies

  • criminal justice
  • legal reform
  • restorative practices

Putting it to work

  • reform systems
  • mediating conflict
  • restoring rights

Questions to consider

  • What is justice?
  • How to restore trust?

Another view

Fear may prevent consent in punishment.

More from Simone Weil

  1. Those who keep the masses of men in subjection by exercising force and cruelty deprive them at once of two vital foods, liberty and obedience; for it is no lon…

    Permalink to quote #27
  2. By a strange mystery - which is connected with the power of the social element - a profession can confer on quite ordinary men in their exercise of it, virtues…

    Permalink to quote #29
  3. It is because of my wretchedness that I am 'I.' It is on account of the wretchedness of the universe that, in a sense, God is 'I' (that is to say a person). [p…

    Permalink to quote #26

Related quotes

  1. A punishment that penalizes without forestalling is indeed called revenge.

    Albert CamusAlbert Camus quote #95
  2. The law which attempts a man's life [capital punishment] is impractical, unjust, inadmissible. It has never repressed crime-for a second crime is every day com…

    Donatien de SadeDonatien de Sade quote #1
  3. If a man put out the eye of another man, his eye shall be put out.

    HammurabiHammurabi quote #3