The aim is to replace economic oligarchies by the State, which has a will-to-power of its own and is quite as little concerned with the public good; and a will-to-power, moreover, which is not economic but military and therefore much more dangerous to any good folk who have a taste for staying alive. And on the bourgeois side what on earth is the sense of objecting to State control in economic affairs if one accepts private monopolies which have all the economic and technical disadvantages of State monopolies and possibly some others as well? [p.230]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Replacing economic oligarchies with the State creates a dangerous military power; opposing State control while accepting private monopolies is inconsistent.
- In plain terms
- Using the State to fix economics just creates military danger, and opposing it while keeping private monopolies makes no sense.
- What can you take from it?
- Swapping private monopolies for State ones is dangerous and inconsistent.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Is State control better than private monopoly?
- What power do you really oppose?
Another view
Some argue State control is safer than private monopoly.
More from Simone Weil
What a country calls its vital economic interests are not the things which enable its citizens to live, but the things which enable it to make war; petrol is m…
Permalink to quote #40 The struggle between the opponents and defenders of capitalism is a struggle between innovators who do not know what innovation to make and conservatives who d…
Permalink to quote #42 'A man thinks he is dying for his country,' said Anatole France, 'but he is dying for a few industrialists.' But even that is saying too much. What one dies fo…
Permalink to quote #39
Related quotes
Taxes are not levied for the benefit of the taxed.
Robert A. HeinleinRobert A. Heinlein quote #127 But now, as throughout history, financial capacity and political perspicacity are inversely correlated.
John Kenneth GalbraithJohn Kenneth Galbraith quote #2 All political arrangements, in that they have to bring a variety of widely-discordant interests into unity and harmony, necessarily occasion manifold collision…
Wilhelm von HumboldtWilhelm von Humboldt quote #15