Skip to content
quotesby

There is an error into which most of the speculators on government have fallen, and which the well-known state of society of our Indians ought, before now, to have corrected. In their hypothesis of the origin of government, they suppose it to have commenced in the patriarchal or monarchical form. Our Indians are evidently in that state of nature which has passed the association of a single family... The Cherokees, the only tribe I know to be contemplating the establishment of regular laws, magistrates, and government, propose a government of representatives, elected from every town. But of all things, they least think of subjecting themselves to the will of one man.

Thomas Jefferson#94

PoliticsHistoryDemocracy

About this quote

What does it mean?
Jefferson challenges the idea that governments naturally start as monarchies, pointing to Cherokee representatives who choose elected leaders over single rulers.
In plain terms
Governments do not have to start as monarchies; the Cherokee choose elected representatives instead.
What can you take from it?
Democracy can arise naturally without needing a king first.

Where it applies

  • political theory
  • indigenous history
  • constitutional debate

Putting it to work

  • study indigenous governance
  • challenge monarchical assumptions
  • elect representatives

Questions to consider

  • How did early governments actually form?
  • What can we learn from indigenous systems?

Another view

The comparison to Cherokee politics may oversimplify complex tribal structures.

More from Thomas Jefferson

  1. I hope we shall take warning from the example [of England] and crush in it's [sic] birth the aristocracy of our monied corporations which dare already to chall…

    Permalink to quote #93
  2. Lay down true principles and adhere to them inflexibly. Do not be frightened into their surrender by the alarms of the timid, or the croakings of wealth agains…

    Permalink to quote #95
  3. I may say Christianity itself divided into it's thousands also, who are disputing, anathematizing and where the laws permit burning and torturing one another f…

    Permalink to quote #92

Related quotes

  1. Having fought most of my life against apartheid - and of course my parents were imprisoned during the struggle - I am thrilled by the way South Africa has deve…

    Peter HainPeter Hain quote #1
  2. It has been observed that a pure democracy if it were practicable would be the most perfect government. Experience has proved that no position is more false th…

    Alexander HamiltonAlexander Hamilton quote #3
  3. We may be proud that England is the ancient country of Parliaments. With scarcely any intervening period, Parliaments have met constantly for 600 years, and th…

    John BrightJohn Bright quote #3