The reader will understand that I despise these 'yellows'; they are utterly without honor, they are vulgar and cruel; and yet, in spite of all their vices, I count them less dangerous to society than the so-called 'respectable' papers, which pretend to all the virtues, and set the smug and pious tone for good society--papers like the 'New York Tribune' and the 'Boston Evening Transcript' and the 'Baltimore Sun,' which are read by rich old gentlemen and maiden aunts, and can hardly ever be forced to admit to their columns any new or vital event or opinion. These are 'kept' papers, in the strictest sense of the term, and do not have to hustle on the street for money. They serve the pocketbooks of the whole propertied class--which is the meaning of the term 'respectability' in the bourgeois world. On the other hand the 'yellow' journals, serving their own pocketbooks exclusively, will often print attacks on vested wealth, provided the attacks are startling and sensational, and provided the vested wealth in question is not a heavy advertiser.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Sinclair argues that openly corrupt yellow papers are less harmful than respectable papers that hide their bias and suppress new ideas to serve the wealthy.
- In plain terms
- Outright bad newspapers are safer than fake good ones that pretend to be virtuous while protecting the status quo.
- What can you take from it?
- Beware of media that claims moral superiority while blocking dissenting voices.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do you identify hidden bias in news?
- What makes a publication truly independent?
Another view
The quote assumes a binary between yellow and respectable papers that may not fit modern media landscapes.
More from Upton Sinclair
The methods by which the 'Empire of Business' maintains its control over journalism are four: First, ownership of the papers; second, ownership of the owners; …
Permalink to quote #22 In the course of my twenty years career as an assailant of special privilege, I have attacked pretty nearly every important interest in America. The statements…
Permalink to quote #24 Journalism is one of the devices whereby industrial autocracy keeps its control over political democracy; it is the day-by-day, between-elections propaganda, w…
Permalink to quote #21
Related quotes
But for the media to name their coverage of the 2003 invasion of Iraq the same as what the Pentagon calls it-everyday seeing 'Operation Iraqi Freedom'-you have…
Amy GoodmanAmy Goodman quote #1 Journalists say a thing that they know isn't true, in the hope that if they keep on saying it long enough it will be true.
Arnold BennettArnold Bennett quote #5 A Government which has decided on embarking on the hazardous and terrible enterprise of war must at the outset present a one-sided case in justification of its…
Arthur PonsonbyArthur Ponsonby quote #10