Whence had they come, The hand and lash that beat down frigid Rome? What sacred drama through her body heaved When world-transforming Charlemagne was conceived? Supernatural Songs, VIII, Whence Had They Come?
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The poem questions the mysterious origins of historical figures and events that changed civilization.
- In plain terms
- Where did the hands that shaped history come from, and what drama happened before great leaders were born?
- What can you take from it?
- Historical change often feels like it comes from a supernatural or unknown source.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Who really shapes history?
- Do leaders come from nowhere?
Another view
The supernatural framing may not align with secular historical analysis.
More from William Butler Yeats
I pray-for word is out And prayer comes round again- That I may seem, though I die old, A foolish, passionate man.
Permalink to quote #149 Then he struggled with the mind; His proud heart he left behind. Now his wars on God begin; At stroke of midnight God shall win. Supernatural Songs, IX, The Fo…
Permalink to quote #151 God guard me from those thoughts men think In the mind alone; He that sings a lasting song Thinks in a marrow-bone.
Permalink to quote #148
Related quotes
Ces deux moities de Dieu, le pape et l'empereur!
Victor HugoVictor Hugo quote #1 I am thankful for the kind treatment during my captivity and I ask God to accept me with mercy.
Hans FrankHans Frank quote #1 Cities and Thrones and Powers, Stand in Time's eye, Almost as long as flowers, Which daily die: But, as new buds put forth To glad new men, Out of the spent an…
Rudyard KiplingRudyard Kipling quote #2