Skip to content
quotesby

The one thing we know about torture is that it was never designed in the first place to get at the actual truth of anything; it was designed in the darkest days of human history to produce false confessions in order to annihilate political and religious dissidents. And that is how it always works: it gets confessions regardless of their accuracy.

Andrew Sullivan#16

TortureHistoryCoercionConfessionTruth

About this quote

What does it mean?
Torture was historically designed to force false confessions, not uncover truth.
In plain terms
Torture aims to make people confess falsely, regardless of accuracy.
What can you take from it?
Torture produces unreliable information by design.

Where it applies

  • human rights review
  • intelligence critique
  • historical study

Putting it to work

  • reject torture
  • evaluate evidence sources

Questions to consider

  • What is the purpose of torture?
  • Can coerced confessions be trusted?

Another view

Some may claim torture yields useful intelligence.

More from Andrew Sullivan

  1. Any president can start a war, and use the chaos of disorder that such a war creates as an indefinite argument for prolonging it. It's a war that keeps on givi…

    Permalink to quote #15
  2. Torture gives false information. And the worst scenarios that tortured detainees coughed up - many of them completely innocent, remember - may well have come t…

    Permalink to quote #17
  3. Previous war-presidents have gathered opponents into their cabinets, reached out to estranged former allies, engaged in aggressive diplomacy to maximize effect…

    Permalink to quote #14

Related quotes

  1. Is it not a rather fantastic historical irony that the torture techniques that the North Vietnamese used against McCain that forced him to offer a videotaped f…

    Andrew SullivanAndrew Sullivan quote #23
  2. Finally, she broke her silence and spelled it out to Dr. Burkley. Kneeling, John Kennedy's personal physician indicated her ghastly skirt with a trembling hand…

    William ManchesterWilliam Manchester quote #1
  3. Fiction has to be plausible. All history has to do is happen.

    Harry TurtledoveHarry Turtledove quote #1