Skip to content
quotesby

When war reaches such dimensions as to involve the whole nation, and when the people at its conclusion find they have gained nothing but only observe widespread calamity around them, they are inclined to become more sceptical and desire to investigate the foundations of the arguments which inspired their patriotism, inflamed their passions, and prepared them to offer the supreme sacrifice. They are curious to know why the ostensible objects for which they fought have none of them been attained, more especially if they are the victors.

Arthur Ponsonby#15

WarPoliticsTruthPatriotismHistoryAccountabilityReflectionSkepticism

About this quote

What does it mean?
After a nation‑wide war, people become skeptical and seek to understand why the patriotic promises failed, especially if they won.
In plain terms
Post‑war, citizens question unmet promises and the war’s purpose.
What can you take from it?
Promote transparent post‑conflict assessments.

Where it applies

  • post‑war elections
  • historical commissions
  • public debates

Putting it to work

  • independent investigations
  • public hearings

Questions to consider

  • What mechanisms encourage honest post‑war evaluation?
  • How does victory affect willingness to question the war?

Another view

Some societies maintain narratives that suppress critical inquiry.

More from Arthur Ponsonby

  1. Another effect of the continual appearance of false and biased statement and the absorption of the lie atmosphere is that deeds of real valour, heroism, and ph…

    Permalink to quote #14
  2. When the generation that has known war is still alive, it is well that they should be given chapter and verse with regard to some of the best-known cries, catc…

    Permalink to quote #16
  3. In calm retrospect we can appreciate better the disastrous effects of the poison of falsehood, whether officially, semi-officially, or privately manufactured. …

    Permalink to quote #13

Related quotes

  1. Of course, it was not a true uprising of the people. It was inspired by America and other agents. The 'Voice of America' really started it.

    Paul RobesonPaul Robeson quote #5
  2. Exstat et sermo eius in senatu percivilis: 'Siquidem locutus aliter fuerit, dabo operam ut rationem factorum meorum dictorumque reddam; si perseveraverit, in v…

    SuetoniusSuetonius quote #10
  3. The sacred obligation to the Union soldiers must not - will not be forgotten nor neglected.... But those who fought against the Nation cannot and do not look t…

    Rutherford B. HayesRutherford B. Hayes quote #55