Skip to content
quotesby

Voluntary taxation, far from impairing the 'State's' credit, would strengthen it. In the first place, the simplification of its functions would greatly reduce, and perhaps entirely abolish, its need to borrow, and the power to borrow is generally inversely proportional to the steadiness of the need. It is usually the inveterate borrower who lacks credit. In the second place, the power of the State to repudiate, and still continue its business, is dependent upon its power of compulsory taxation. It knows that, when it can no longer borrow, it can at least tax its citizens up to the limit of revolution. In the third place, the State is trusted, not because it is over and above individuals, but because the lender presumes that it desires to maintain its credit and will therefore pay its debts. This desire for credit will be stronger in a 'State' supported by voluntary taxation than in the State which enforces taxation.

Benjamin Tucker#23

ReformCreditFinanceTaxation

About this quote

What does it mean?
Voluntary taxation would improve a state's credit by reducing borrowing needs and increasing reliance on stable revenue.
In plain terms
Letting citizens choose to pay taxes makes the government more financially stable and trustworthy.
What can you take from it?
Voluntary contribution systems can enhance institutional creditworthiness.

Where it applies

  • economics
  • public finance
  • government reform

Putting it to work

  • budget reform
  • tax policy analysis

Questions to consider

  • Would voluntary systems fund essential services?
  • Does credit depend on compulsion?

Another view

It overlooks potential revenue shortfalls if contributions are too low.

More from Benjamin Tucker

  1. Why, the very first act of the State, the compulsory assessment and collection of taxes, is itself an aggression, a violation of equal liberty, and, as such, i…

    Permalink to quote #22
  2. The Anarchists never have claimed that liberty will bring perfection; they simply say that its results are vastly preferable to those that follow authority.

    Permalink to quote #24
  3. 'But,' it will be asked of the Anarchists at this point in the argument, 'what shall be done with those individuals who undoubtedly will persist in violating t…

    Permalink to quote #21

Related quotes

  1. The idea of abolishing Income Tax is to me highly attractive, both on other grounds & because it tends to public economy.

    William Ewart GladstoneWilliam Ewart Gladstone quote #12
  2. Less than fifteen cents to the province and more than twenty-five cents to Ottawa, this is far from being excessive!

    Maurice DuplessisMaurice Duplessis quote #1
  3. Economy is the first and great article (economy such as I understand it) in my financial creed. The controversy between direct and indirect taxation holds a mi…

    William Ewart GladstoneWilliam Ewart Gladstone quote #3