Skip to content
quotesby

My wife Margaret and I sold our house to Sir Roger Penrose and his wife... Talking to Roger, I found we both agreed that AI, as they call it, is not going to be achieved by present-day machines. 'Artificial Intelligence' - that makes it sound simple, but what you're really talking about is artificial consciousness, AC. And I don't think there's any way we can achieve artificial consciousness, at least until we've understood the sources of our own consciousness. I believe consciousness is a mind/body creation, literally interwoven with the body and the body's support systems. Well, you don't get that sort of thing with a robot.

Brian Aldiss#53

PhilosophyConsciousnessMindBody

About this quote

What does it mean?
Artificial consciousness is not possible with current machines and requires understanding our own mind/body connection first.
In plain terms
Robots can't be conscious yet because we don't understand how our bodies make minds.
What can you take from it?
You can't build conscious machines until you understand your own consciousness.

Where it applies

  • tech debates
  • philosophical study
  • ai research

Putting it to work

  • study consciousness
  • evaluate ai claims
  • explore mind body link

Questions to consider

  • Can machines be conscious?
  • How does the body shape the mind?

Another view

It assumes consciousness is strictly physical and cannot be replicated differently.

More from Brian Aldiss

  1. That first novel of mine, Non-Stop, is directly attributable to Heinlein. His 'Common Sense' seemed to me such a good story, but bereft of any human feelings. …

    Permalink to quote #52
  2. I can't help believing that these things that come from the subconscious mind have a sort of truth to them. It may not be a scientific truth, but it's psycholo…

    Permalink to quote #54
  3. I'm lucky that SFWA has such a short memory. I was always the Young Turk, the gadfly. Part of the New Wave, although I didn't fit in there either! I spent year…

    Permalink to quote #51

Related quotes

  1. I believe that there is a necessary connection in both directions between the physical and the mental, but that it cannot be discovered a priori. Opinion is st…

    Thomas NagelThomas Nagel quote #1
  2. The body is the outermost layer of the mind.

    David MitchellDavid Mitchell quote #7
  3. Man's consciousness not only reflects the objective world, but creates it.

    Vladimir LeninVladimir Lenin quote #10