I believe that there is a necessary connection in both directions between the physical and the mental, but that it cannot be discovered a priori. Opinion is strongly divided on the credibility of some kind of functionalist reductionism, and I won't go through my reasons for being on the antireductionist side of that debate. Despite significant attempts by a number of philosophers to describe the functional manifestations of conscious mental states, I continue to believe that no purely functionalist characterization of a system entails-simply in virtue of our mental concepts-that the system is conscious.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Physical and mental states are connected but require empirical study.
- In plain terms
- Mind and body are linked but we need to study how.
- What can you take from it?
- Consciousness cannot be fully explained by function alone.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can machines ever be truly conscious?
Another view
Functionalism might still offer partial explanations of mind.
More from Thomas Nagel
The problem is one of opposition between subjective and objective points of view. There is a tendency to seek an objective account of everything before admitti…
Permalink to quote #2 Eventually, I believe, current attempts to understand the mind by analogy with man-made computers that can perform superbly some of the same external tasks as …
Permalink to quote #3 Everyone is entitled to commit murder in the imagination once in a while, not to mention lesser infractions.
Permalink to quote #4
Related quotes
My wife Margaret and I sold our house to Sir Roger Penrose and his wife... Talking to Roger, I found we both agreed that AI, as they call it, is not going to b…
Brian AldissBrian Aldiss quote #53 The body is the outermost layer of the mind.
David MitchellDavid Mitchell quote #7 Man's consciousness not only reflects the objective world, but creates it.
Vladimir LeninVladimir Lenin quote #10