Skip to content
quotesby

Aldiss' New Wave masterpiece is Report On Probability A. ... The minuteae of all the involved's lives are the only thing; the act of observation is the only plot. The science fiction happens when it becomes apparent that there are Other watchers, and watchers watching those watchers, stretching back to what seems to be citizens of our own reality. Report On Probability A is about the metaphor of circular vision, manifested in the narrative by the round fields of view of the various optical devices and windows through which S, G, and C observe their world, expanding macrocosmically with the vast circle of observers observing the observers. As banality merges with paranoia, drawn only by whatever the reader brings to the narrative, there is no conclusion, no story, only facts. The story returns over and over to the painting The Hireling Shepherd by Holman Hunt, which becomes a recurring unresolved image which has no final meaning, only whatever speculation it's benighted observers bring to bear on it. Every character is searching for a meaning which may, or may not, exist as actual Truth. Behind each level of truth lies another; who is to say how far the chain goes or which part of it is more Actual? ... The simplicity of the 'story' masks an investigation into uncertainty and the nature of reality itself. The seeming bankruptcy of plot opens the reader to question the act of observation, of reporting, of writing itself. Truth is what Report On Probability A is all about, and Aldiss points out that it is a plastic thing that depends on who is trying to figure it out, and an ambiguous thing that may, at it's root, be unknowable.

Brian Aldiss#62

Science fictionPhilosophyNarrativeObservationSurveillance

About this quote

What does it mean?
A book review describing a story about watching observers and circular observation.
In plain terms
The book is about people watching others watch them.
What can you take from it?
Surveillance creates recursive reality.

Where it applies

  • literary analysis
  • reading sci-fi

Putting it to work

  • writing metafiction
  • studying surveillance

Questions to consider

  • Is being watched dangerous?
  • Does observation change reality?

Another view

The lack of plot may alienate readers.

More from Brian Aldiss

  1. That's the artist's role - to strike out always for something new, to break away, to defy, to... grapple with the unfamiliar.

    Permalink to quote #61
  2. It is comparatively easy to become a writer; staying a writer, resisting formulaic work, generating one's own creativity - that's a much tougher matter.

    Permalink to quote #60
  3. I am a writer and always was; being a writer is an integral part of my identity. Being published, being well regarded, is a component of that identity.

    Permalink to quote #59

Related quotes

  1. The observer is the observed.

    Jiddu KrishnamurtiJiddu Krishnamurti quote #1
  2. Ghostwritten's secret agenda is to offer up eight different answers to the question, 'Why do things happen?' so it has the right to monkey about with time and …

    David MitchellDavid Mitchell quote #1
  3. I don't see any god up here.

    Yuri GagarinYuri Gagarin quote #2