Audiences and critics acknowledge that a play or concerto gains force in great rendition. A good play may overcome bad staging. A great concerto may survive a poor soloist. But it is naturally assumed that a more accomplished performance intensifies the impact of the work. The play's text or concerto's score does not change, but the right actors and musicians help realize its full potential. Among contemporary literary critics, however, one never encounters this notion in regard to books and printing. To recognize the sensual contributions of the physical elements of a book is somehow assumed to demean the spiritual purity of the text. To notice the book itself smacks of philistinism, and to make distinctions based on paper, binding, and typography brings accusations of elitism or decadence.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Gioia argues critics ignore physical book qualities unlike performance arts, fearing it diminishes the text's spiritual purity.
- In plain terms
- Critics overlook how physical book design affects reading like performance affects plays.
- What can you take from it?
- Value physical book design alongside textual content.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How does a book feel?
- What matters in a book?
Another view
Textual content can stand alone without physical embellishment.
More from Dana Gioia
What we conceal Is always more than what we dare confide. Think of the letters that we write our dead.
Permalink to quote #12 What does an instinctively popular poet do in contemporary America, where serious poetry is no longer a popular art? The public whose values and sensibility he…
Permalink to quote #14 This is not work but a kind of workmanship. First out of paper, then from the body. To provoke thought into form, molded according to a measure. I think of a t…
Permalink to quote #11
Related quotes
Get stewed: Books are a load of crap.
Philip LarkinPhilip Larkin quote #1 Books are not made to be believed, but to be subjected to inquiry.
Umberto EcoUmberto Eco quote #5 From the moment I picked your book up until I laid it down I was convulsed with laughter. Someday I intend reading it.
Groucho MarxGroucho Marx quote #11